Best Life Insurance In Erie, PA

For the best life insurance company in Erie, I’d recommend Northwestern Mutual.

min read -
Updated: 12 October 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Selecting the right life insurance policy is crucial to secure your loved ones’ future and maintain their lifestyle if something happens to you. In Erie, Northwestern Mutual stands out as my top choice overall.

Their prices might not be the absolute lowest, but their products are excellent, backed by the largest life insurance company in the US.

In this review, I’ll explore various life insurance policies like whole, term, and guaranteed issue options. I’ll also look into the average costs for different categories in Erie, helping you find the perfect policy for your specific needs. It’s essential to pick the right company and policy to avoid long-term financial struggles for your loved ones.

With my prior experience as a career agent and extensive knowledge about the companies discussed in this review, I can assure you that they all cater to different demographics while maintaining financial stability and providing exceptional customer service.

Best Life Insurance Companies In Erie, PA 2024

Best Life Insurance, Erie 2024

Compare The Best Life Insurance Companies In Erie, Pennsylvania

This table shows our preferred picks, carefully selected based on specific criteria. Take a look and find the perfect fit for your needs!

Overall Rating Best For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating Online Experience Get A Quote
Northwestern Mutual
4.9

Best Overall

A++

794

9.5

Instant Quote
Penn Mutual
4.8

Best Overall Runner-Up

A+

Not Rated

9.6

Instant Quote
MassMutual
4.7

Best For Seniors

A++

780

9.5

Instant Quote
Transamerica
4.5

Best For Young Adults

A+

740

9.4

Instant Quote
Nationwide
4.8

Best For Cheapest Life Insurance

A+

791

9.6

Instant Quote
USAA
4.6

Families

A++

Not Rated

9.8

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Our Methodology

Here's the scoop! We take into account a bunch of things, like how customers rate their service, what products they offer, their prices, and how smooth their online experience is. And hey, my own background in selling life insurance and dealing with agents from other companies has really influenced my views and given me some super valuable insights into what they've got to offer. So you can trust that we've got a well-rounded methodology to guide our opinions!

32

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

16

Brands Reviewed

23+

Research Hours

Reviews Of The Best Life Insurance Companies In Erie


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Northwestern Mutual is the biggest life insurance seller in the United States. They offer both term and permanent life insurance policies. Their term life insurance can also be converted to a permanent policy, without having to undergo a medical exam.

In Erie, Northwestern Mutual has become the leader in the life insurance market, establishing dominance with the largest market share out of all insurance companies.

However, It’s not just high-budget advertising that got them there. Instead, it’s a result of their commitment to educating people on the importance of taking out life insurance, whilst also guiding them to pick the right policy for their needs.

Their agents typically stay with Northwestern for long periods of time, which leads to high policy retention rates and good financial stability. Thereby making Northwestern one of the most secure insurance companies in the market.

In 2023, Northwestern Mutual is estimated to pay out $6.8 Billion in dividends to policyholders.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Few complaints filed with state regulators
  • Wide range of products available
  • Reliable claims-paying ability
Drawbacks
  • Higher rates compared to competitors
  • Limited availability through company agents only
  • No option to get quotes or apply online

Best Overall Runner-Up

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Right on the outskirts of Erie, in Horsham, Pennsylvania, you’ll find Penn Mutual, ranking among the top ten most popular life insurance companies in the city in terms of market share.

This historic insurer has a solid reputation for paying dividends and boasts impressive financial ratings. You can count on them for high coverage no-exam life insurance and affordable term life policies.

Penn Mutual stands in the top 15% of all life insurance companies when it comes to low complaints, based on information from The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). This data shows that in 2022, they had only two customer complaints, and in 2021, there were just ten.

With Penn Mutual, you may get some policies without even needing a medical exam. This includes larger policies with face amounts going as high as $7.5 million. Moreover, coverage might even get approved on the same day.

They’ve earned the spot as our runner-up for Best Overall because they are a strong company with headquarters in The Keystone State, who have a strong history of paying dividends, (they’ve been paying out dividends to their policyholders for 174 years).

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • You've got options – term and permanent policies to choose from.
  • Very few customer complaints – they're doing something right!
  • They've got a solid history of paying dividends – that's some financial stability right there!
Drawbacks
  • Here's the catch – limited website info available.
  • No online quotes – you'll have to get in touch with an agent.
  • Buying only through agents – so no DIY online purchase option.

Best For Seniors

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

MassMutual have been around since 1851 and have a variety of life insurance policies on offer, such as; term, whole, and universal life. Their variable universal life insurance lets you play around with flexible premiums and investment opportunities.

MassMutual are a well-known and trusted name, especially among seniors. They’ve earned that loyalty through consistent advertising, and their strong reputation for financial stability.

Some seniors worry about smaller or unfamiliar insurance companies not being able to pay out death benefits, but with MassMutual, that concern is non-existent.

MassMutual’s premiums are also very competitive, especially for seniors in the Erie market. They might not be known for having the cheapest premiums, but they have been very aggressive with their pricing for seniors.

We selected MassMutual as the top life insurance company for seniors because they offer very low rates and also for the security they provide seniors. Older adults want their families to be financially protected by a highly rated life insurer and MassMutual is such a company.

They’ve got an A++ (Superior) rating from AM Best, the highest financial strength rating possible. Plus, they scored way above average in overall customer satisfaction in J.D. Power’s 2022 U.S. Individual Life Insurance Study.

Seniors especially need those low rates because the cost of life insurance keeps increasing as they get older. They’re a top choice for retirees living on fixed incomes.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Seniors, listen up! This one's for you – the lowest rates in Erie.
  • Financially sound – this company's got stability.
  • They're all about seniors – totally committed to serving this market.
Drawbacks
  • Heads up! You can only buy through MassMutual agents.
  • For seniors, no guaranteed issue policy available.
  • Sorry, no online purchase option – you'll need to go the traditional route.

Best Life Insurance Companies For Seniors In Erie, PA

(Average age 60, average weight of 194, average coverage need of $93,000)

Company Rates for $93,000 Coverage
Mutual of Omaha $41
Progressive Life $67
Nationwide $43
State Farm $50
MassMutual $41

Best For Young Adults

Overall Rating
4.5

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Transamerica is a top rated life insurance provider in Erie, and they’ve got an extensive network of independent agents selling their policies. Their standout feature is their term life insurance, which is highly affordable for young adults.

Transamerica knows that many young adults like to do their insurance shopping online, so they’ve made it simple to get a quick quote right from their website.

For people who prefer a personal touch, they also have a “Locate an Agent” button on the website. It’ll help you find a local agent who can walk you through all the options and find the perfect policy to fit your needs.

In a nutshell, Transamerica is all about keeping things affordable and user-friendly. So, if you’re on the hunt for life insurance in Erie, they’re definitely a top choice.

Transamerica’s meets a special need of young adults in Erie, which is affordability. Offering cheap life insurance to young adults helps to protect many young families, and Transamerica provide that with competitively prices life insurance with high face amounts.

Luckily for young people, they’re seen as less risky to life insurance companies, which means they can claim lower premium rates.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Guess what? You can grab term life insurance right from the comfort of your couch – online purchase option!
  • Looking for a big coverage? They've got you covered – up to $10 million policy face amounts.
  • Here's some good news – no medical exam needed for up to $2 million, if you qualify.
Drawbacks
  • Heads up! The minimum term life insurance face amount available is $25,000.
  • Keep in mind, Final Expense Policy isn't guaranteed issue.
  • Their J.D. Power customer satisfaction score might not be top-notch.

Best Life Insurance Companies For Young People In Erie, PA

(Male, average age of 25, average weight of 165, average coverage need of $310,000)

Company Rates for $310,000 Coverage
Progressive Life $23
Prudential $20
MassMutual $18
AAA $23
Mutual of Omaha $19
Transamerica $17

Best For Families

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

While USAA mostly focus on military families for their insurance products, they’ve made an exception for life insurance. Now, any U.S. citizen or permanent resident can obtain a life insurance policy from them, even without a military connection.

Instead, they’ll look at factors like age, health, lifestyle, and they might ask for a medical exam in some cases.

USAA’s got an A+ rating from A.M. Best, showing off their impressive financial strength and ability to pay claims.

However, while their life insurance is open to everyone, their other products are still exclusive to military families. So, if you want all your insurance policies in one place, it might not be as convenient for non-military customers.

They’ve got a team called “Survivor Relations” that’s dedicated to helping beneficiaries of deceased policyholders sort things out across all their USAA accounts and policies.

Moreover, USAA also provides a guaranteed issue life insurance policy in partnership with Mutual of Omaha. It’s available right here in Erie, and you won’t even need a medical exam to qualify.

USAA is our Best option for Families, because they’re now available to all U.S. families with affordable rates. Their commitment to helping bereaved families is exceptional.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Great news for non-military citizens and permanent residents – life insurance is available to you!
  • They've got a wide range of life insurance products – term, whole, and universal life.
  • And here's a bonus – no exam needed for some term life policies.
Drawbacks
  • They don't have as many term life plans as some competitors.
  • Auto and home insurance not open to non-military families – sorry about that.
  • If you're not aged 21 to 35, Essential Term is off-limits.

Best For Cheapest Life Insurance

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Looking for affordable life insurance in Erie? Nationwide has you covered. They’re famous for offering the lowest rates around, beating out other insurers in the area.

Their life insurance policies include term and permanent policies, like whole life, universal life, and variable universal life insurance. They’ve even got a no-exam life insurance plan for a hassle-free option.

Nationwide brings in a team of well-trained career and independent agents, ready to give you accurate pricing and excellent service. With plenty of neighborhood offices in Erie, finding a local agent is easy. If you prefer, you can give their home office a call, and they’ll connect you with an agent who’ll take care of all your needs.

Nationwide possess superior financial ratings and high customer satisfaction scores, earning them a spot among the best life insurance companies in Erie. Nationwide offers quality protection at an affordable price.

Nationwide takes the title for Best for Cheap Life Insurance because of its cheap premiums. Having the lowest premiums in Erie is a major plus, but it’s not just about being cheap. Nationwide doesn’t sacrifice quality for low rates. Therefore, you get the best of both worlds.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Nationwide's got you covered with an extensive network of well-trained agents selling their policies.
  • You won't be disappointed with their range of life insurance products – they've got it all!
  • And here's the best part – they offer the best rates in Erie. You're in for a treat!
Drawbacks
  • If you're applying for term life, make sure you're 70 or younger.
  • But wait, there's more – no online quotes or applications for permanent products. You'll need to take the traditional route.

How To Find The Best Life Insurance Company For You

When you’re on the search for insurance companies, keep this in mind – each one offers policies to suit your specific needs. Now, depending on your situation, one company might be a better match for you than others.

For example, if you’re 25 and want $250,000 of whole life insurance, Transamerica could be your best option. But, if you’re 65, MassMutual might be more suitable.

However, if you prefer to buy insurance online, companies like Haven Life could be just what you’re looking for. To find your perfect fit, ask yourself these five questions:

1. Check their financial ratings.

2. See if they offer the policy you need.

3. Decide if you want a local agent’s help or prefer to search online.

4. Make sure their rates are competitive for your age group.

5. Check those online reviews – are they mostly positive?

Remember, everyone’s needs are unique. What works for others might not be the best fit for you, so go ahead and find what suits you best!

Best Cheap Life Insurance Companies In Erie For Females

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
State Farm $17 $31
Nationwide $11 $16
Mutual of Omaha $12 $18
MassMutual $10 $15
Transamerica $12 $20
Progressive Life $15 $42
AAA $14 $28

Best Cheap Life Insurance Companies In Erie For Males

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
Progressive Life $26 $52
Nationwide $11 $19
MassMutual $10 $19
Prudential Life $23 $58
Mutual of Omaha $12 $20
Transamerica $17 $31
State Farm $20 $31

Largest Life Insurance Companies In Erie, PA

There are dozens of life insurance companies doing business in Erie. These are the five largest as measured by market share:

Company Market Share
Northwestern Mutual 7.49%
Prudential 6.61%
Metropolitan 6.32%
New York Life 6.31
MassMutual 6.29%

Average Cost Of Life Insurance In Erie, PA

Best Cheap Life Insurance Companies In Erie For Females

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
State Farm $17 $31
Nationwide $11 $16
Mutual of Omaha $12 $18
MassMutual $10 $15
Transamerica $12 $20
Progressive Life $15 $42
AAA $14 $28

Best Cheap Life Insurance Companies In Erie For Males

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
Progressive Life $26 $52
Nationwide $11 $19
MassMutual $10 $19
Prudential Life $23 $58
Mutual of Omaha $12 $20
Transamerica $17 $31
State Farm $20 $31

Best Life Insurance Companies For Young People In Erie, PA

(Male, average age of 25, average weight of 158, average coverage need of $280,00,000)

Company Rates for $310,000 Coverage
Progressive Life $23
Prudential $20
MassMutual $18
AAA $23
Mutual of Omaha $19
Transamerica $17

Best Life Insurance Companies For Seniors In Erie, PA

(Average age 60, average weight of 186, average coverage need of $85,000)

Company Rates for $93,000 Coverage
Mutual of Omaha $41
Progressive Life $67
Nationwide $43
State Farm $50
MassMutual $41

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Life Insurance In Erie

The cost of life insurance in Erie depends on various factors, like these:

The insurance company: Different companies charge different rates.

Gender: Men typically pay more because they have a shorter life expectancy. If you have pre-existing medical conditions, your rates may go up.

Smoker or Nonsmoker: Smokers pay more due to shorter lifespans.

Credit Score: Insurers in Erie may use your credit score to calculate your rate.

Riders: Adding extras like disability waiver or child rider can bump up your policy cost.

Pennsylvania Life Insurance Laws To Know

In Pennsylvania, life insurance companies play by the state rules, protecting policyholders through these regulations:

Contestable Period:
For two years from the policy’s start date, the insurance company can reject claims if they find inaccurate or false info on the application.

Free Look Period:

You’ve got ten days to review your policy. If you change your mind, return it for a full refund of the premiums you paid.

Surrender Penalties:

When you buy insurance, the seller must be upfront about any charges or fees mentioned in the contract. No surprises!

In The News

WHTM News in Pennsylvania reported on September 29, 2022, that state officials are really stressing the significance of life insurance.

Here’s what Johnathan Greer, the President, and CEO of the Insurance Federation of Pennsylvania had to say: “Having been through it myself, losing a family member can throw you for a loop, both mentally and emotionally. But guess what? Life insurance comes to the rescue, giving you that much-needed financial stability during such tough times.”

Information About Erie

Erie, also known as the Gem City, is a vibrant hub in the northwestern United States. Its history stretches back to the early days, playing a significant role in the region’s development. Today, Erie boasts its own unique landmarks, like the Bicentennial Tower and Presque Isle State Park, a natural gem attracting tourists and locals alike.

This city is a haven for art and culture lovers, with outstanding museums like the Erie Art Museum and Warner Theatre. Sports enthusiasts also find their place here, cheering for teams like the Erie SeaWolves and BayHawks.

Erie’s culinary scene is diverse, offering everything from local favorites like Smith’s Hot Dogs to innovative eateries. Home to universities like Gannon University, Erie thrives as an educational center. The neighborhoods, like Little Italy and Downtown, bring together the perfect blend of history and modern life, making Erie a unique and charming destination.

FAQs

Is life insurance more expensive in Erie?

When it comes to life insurance in Erie, the prices are pretty much on par with other places. Your age, health history, height, weight, and whether you smoke or not – these are the factors that determine how much you’ll pay for your policy.

How much per month is a million dollar life insurance policy in Erie?

Here’s the deal – in Erie, your gender can affect the cost of a million-dollar life insurance policy. For about $22 per month, you could grab one, but keep in mind, the price may vary based on whether you’re a man or a woman.

What is the average monthly cost of life insurance in Erie?

Listen up, folks! In Erie, you’re looking at an average of around $17 for a 10-year term life policy. That’s the ballpark figure you’ll want to keep in mind when shopping for life insurance.

Go back to top