The Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For 2024

American National is well-regarded for its dependable and affordably priced basic car insurance in Colorado, costing $19 per month.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 15 November 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Though affordable car insurance may seem elusive in Colorado, it’s within reach if you know where to look. American National is a respected name in insurance, offering competitive rates and a wide range of coverage options. As living expenses continue to climb, finding affordable insurance with the coverage you need is critical.

Whether you’re a new driver, a regular on the road, or a family seeking lower premiums, understanding the factors that affect rates and learning where to find the best deals can make all the difference. Drawing on more than ten years of research, I’ve created this guide to help you find affordable insurance in Colorado.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Colorado, 2024

amer
Cheapest For Minimum Coverage - American National
amer
Cheapest For Full Coverage - American National
amer
Cheapest For Seniors - American National
American National Logo
Cheapest For Young Drivers - American National 
American National Logo
Cheapest For Good Drivers - American National 
Cheapest Car Insurance, Colorado, 2024

Our Methodology

Throughout my research, I employed a methodical strategy to collect and analyze data concerning various car insurance providers and their policies. Initially, I pinpointed critical elements to investigate, including coverage options, pricing, customer satisfaction, and financial stability. Subsequently, I gathered information from credible sources such as insurance company websites, consumer review platforms, and industry publications. After compiling the data, I categorized it and assessed each insurer based on predetermined criteria. This process involved comparing coverage options, premium rates, discounts, and customer feedback to identify the strengths and weaknesses of each provider.

65

Quotes Assessed

35+

Hours Of Research

15+

Years Of Industry Expertise

22

Brands Reviews

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Minimum Coverage

For minimum car insurance in Colorado, American National stands out with rates as low as $19 per month.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
American National $19 $228
Colorado Farm Bureau $20 $235
Geico $24 $288
USAA $31 $376
Auto-owners $38 $456

In Colorado, drivers are obligated to maintain minimum car insurance to drive legally, typically encompassing liability coverage for bodily injury and property damage. Bodily injury liability assists with medical expenses and legal fees in the event you are liable for an accident that causes harm to others, whereas property damage liability covers the costs of repairing or replacing another person’s property or vehicle if you are responsible for the damage. These minimum coverage thresholds are established by state law and may vary based on your driving record or vehicle type. Being informed about these mandates is crucial for ensuring adequate financial security.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Full Coverage

In Colorado, drivers can find budget-friendly full coverage car insurance through American National, with monthly rates starting at $106.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
American National $106 $1,282
Colorado Farm Bureau $124 $1,485
Geico $129 $1,551
Auto-Owners $153 $1,841
USAA $191 $2,286

In Colorado, drivers can choose full coverage car insurance that goes beyond the mandatory liability insurance by including collision and comprehensive options. Collision coverage pays for car repairs following an accident, irrespective of fault, while comprehensive coverage protects against non-accident-related incidents like theft or fire. Opting for full coverage ensures financial stability and confidence in facing various risks. It’s crucial to review policy specifics, such as coverage limits and deductibles, to ensure it meets individual requirements effectively.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Drivers With Poor Credit

In Colorado, Geico is notable for providing the cheapest insurance rates to drivers with poor credit, averaging about $125 per month.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico $125 $1,497
Nationwide 200 $2,396
State Farm $271 $3,247
Auto-Owners $278 $3,330
Farmers $321 $3,843

Credit scores significantly impact car insurance rates in Colorado. Insurers use credit history to gauge risk, meaning lower scores may lead to higher premiums. Drivers with poor credit are considered higher-risk and more prone to filing claims. Despite these challenges, they can lower insurance costs by shopping around for quotes and leveraging available discounts.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Seniors

For seniors in Colorado, American National stands out as the most economical option, with a typical monthly cost of $59.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
American National $59 $706
GEICO $80 $957
Auto-Owners Insurance $82 $981
State Farm $92 $1,098
Progressive $103 $1,239

Seniors can often get lower car insurance premiums, as they’re generally seen as skilled and responsible drivers. Many older adults drive fewer miles, reducing their likelihood of accidents. Insurers sometimes provide senior discounts based on age and cautious driving, with more savings available for those who take a defensive driving course to improve safety.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Young Drivers

Young adult drivers in Colorado can usually get more affordable car insurance rates than teens. This is largely because they have safer driving habits, which lead to fewer accidents and claims. Insurance companies reward these behaviors with lower premiums for young adults who demonstrate responsibility on the road.

Cheapest Colorado Car Insurance For 16-Year-Olds

Southern Farm Bureau features the most economical rates for sixteen-year-olds, with an average monthly payment of $355.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico $498 $5,967
State Farm $658 $7,891
Allstate $769 $9,228
Southern Farm Bureau $355 $4,257
Auto-Owners $454 $5,446

Cheapest Colorado Car Insurance For 17-Year-Olds

The most economical insurance rates for seventeen-year-olds are offered by American National, with premiums averaging $227.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
USAA $415 $4,975
Geico $446 $5,345
Auto-Owners $451 $5,413
American National $227 $2,721
Southern Farm Bureau $285 $3,411

Cheapest Colorado Car Insurance For 18-Year-Olds

American National has the best deal on insurance for 18-year-olds, with a typical monthly cost of $217.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
USAA $374 $4,489
Geico $388 $4,648
Auto-Owners $416 $4,982
American National $217 $2,602
Southern Farm Bureau $268 $3,210

Cheapest Colorado Car Insurance For 21-Year-Olds

American National is the economical choice for 21-year-olds, with premiums averaging $184 each month.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
USAA $228 $2,735
Southern Farm Bureau $230 $2,756
Auto-Owners $360 $4,317
American National $184 $2,200
Geico $208 $2,487
 

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Good Drivers

American National boasts the least expensive insurance premiums in Colorado, averaging $106 per month for safe drivers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
American National $106 $1,282
Colorado Farm Bureau $124 $1,485
Geico $129 $1,551
Auto-Owners $153 $1,841
USAA $191 $2,286

The cost of auto insurance for safe drivers in Colorado can vary based on factors such as their driving history, age, and desired coverage. Generally, those with a clean driving record may qualify for lower premiums because insurers perceive them as less risky. They may also qualify for discounts for consistently maintaining a good driving record. Safe drivers should consider comparing quotes from several insurers to find competitive rates and coverage options that meet their needs.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Drivers With Prior Incidents

Individuals in Colorado who have been involved in accidents, received speeding tickets, or been convicted of DUIs often struggle to find affordable car insurance. These incidents designate them as high-risk to insurers, leading to higher premiums to account for expected claims. This issue is notably prevalent in Colorado due to its elevated rate of traffic incidents. Insurers develop their pricing strategies based on statistical analyses that indicate a connection between previous driving incidents and a heightened likelihood of future claims.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Drivers With A Speeding Ticket

American National stands out for drivers with speeding tickets, offering average premiums of $303.

Provider Avg. Annual Min Coverage Premium Avg. Annual Full Coverage Premium
USAA
$522
$2,866
Progressive
$554
$3,610
California Casualty
$636
$4,455
American National
$303
$1,648
Geico
$329
$2,006

 Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Drivers With An At-Fault Accident

Choose American National if you’ve got speeding tickets; they offer competitive rates with an average premium of $303.

Provider Avg. Annual Min Coverage Premium Avg. Annual Full Coverage Premium
USAA
$676 $3,352
California Casualty $805 $4,948
Progressive $848 $4,763
American National
$303
$1,648
Geico
$420
$2,627

 Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado For Drivers After A DUI

American National is the top choice for drivers with DUIs, thanks to its low average premium of $408.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico
$592 $3,023
California Casualty $915 $5,044
USAA $964 $4,959
American National
$408
$2,024
Progressive
$489
$3,457

Average Cost Of Car Insurance In Colorado

 Average Cost In Colorado – By Age

Age Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
16 $520 $6,231
17 $444 $5,320
18 $398 $4,768
19 $467 $5,597
21 $360 $4,322
25 $269 $3,223
35 $253 $3,030
45 $231 $2,772
55 $213 $2,556
65 $218 $2,609
75 $259 $3,107

 Average Cost In Colorado- By Gender & Marital Status

Gender Marital Status Average Annual Cost
Female Single $1,720
Male Single $1,718
Female Married $1,650
Male Married $1,636

 Average Cost In Colorado – By Credit Tier

Credit Tier Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Excellent $125 $1,498
Good $159 $1,910
Fair $183 $2,202
Poor $251 $3,017

 Cheapest Car Insurance In Colorado By City:

City Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Denver $283 $3,398
Fort Collins $215 $2,577
Fountain $264 $3,171
Arvada $238 $2,854
Aurora $272 $3,268

Minimum Car Insurance Requirement In Colorado

Colorado drivers are legally required to have a minimum level of car insurance that includes liability coverage of 25/50/15—$25,000 per injured person, $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 for property damage. They must also carry uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage at $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. PIP isn’t required to help cover medical expenses and lost wages, though an eligible health plan can replace PIP under the HIP option.

 

Car Insurance Discounts In Colorado

Checking out car insurance discounts can help you reduce costs, and your agent may suggest others. Here’s a list of common discounts:

  • Safe Driver Discount: For maintaining a clean driving history.
  • Multi-Vehicle Discount: Insuring multiple cars together can lower your rates.
  • Bundling Discount: Get reduced premiums by combining car insurance with other policies, like homeowners.
  • Good Student Discount: Students with strong academic records may be eligible for lower rates.
  • Defensive Driving Discount: Completing a defensive driving course can qualify you for a discount.

FAQs

How much is car insurance a month in Colorado?

The monthly cost of car insurance in Colorado varies, affected by factors including age, driving history, and chosen coverage.

What is the minimum car insurance one must have in Colorado?

In Colorado, it’s necessary for drivers to have car insurance that provides liability coverage for bodily injury and property damage.

Which insurance is better in Colorado?

Selecting the ideal insurance in Colorado depends on your coverage requirements, driving style, and personal preferences. It’s a good idea to compare quotes from various insurers to find the best fit.

Go back to top