Cheapest and Best Motorcycle Insurance in Indiana October, 2024

For individuals prioritizing low costs, Harley-Davidson (Sentry Insurance) stands out with its affordable $22 monthly premium.

min read -
Published:
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Finding the right motorcycle insurance in Indiana can be tough. But don’t worry; you’re exactly where you need to be to tackle this. The best provider, in our opinion, offers excellent coverage and stellar customer service.

With 15 years in the insurance business, I’ve witnessed how inadequate motorcycle insurance can cause issues. It’s not just about legal requirements; it’s about protecting your valuable investment.

With years of expertise behind it, our guide is here to help you avoid pitfalls and choose the most reliable and affordable options for your motorcycle.

 

Best Motorcycle Insurance In Indiana 2024

harley-davidson-logo-wallpapers-wallpaper-cave-min_gnd9vk
Best Overall - Harley-Davidson (Sentry)
USAA-emblem
Best for Military Members - USAA (Progressive)
Best Motorcycle Insurance, Indiana, 2024

Compare The Best Motorcycle Insurance Companies In Indiana

Overall Rating Cheapest For AM Best Rating J.D. Power Rating Online Experience Get A Quote
Harley-Davidson
4.9

Overall

A+

Not Rated

9/10

Instant Quote
GEICO
4.8

Bundling Insurance

A++

830

9/10

Instant Quote
USAA
4.6

Military Members

A+

809

7/10

Instant Quote
Allstate
4.7

Customer Service

A++

816

8/10

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Motorcycle Insurance Companies in Indiana


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Satisfaction
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For the best motorcycle insurance in Indiana, Harley Davidson stands out with its comprehensive policies and top-notch service through Sentry Insurance. This collaboration offers a unique benefit.

Supported by Sentry, a prominent name in the insurance industry, Harley Davidson’s policies provide policyholders with reliability and financial stability. Sentry’s A+ rating from AM Best showcases their competence in meeting policyholder commitments.

In the varied and demanding riding landscape of Indiana, Harley Davidson’s insurance, supported by Sentry, meets the diverse needs of motorcyclists. These policies offer extensive coverage and excellent customer service, making them a smart investment for riders.

The combination of Harley Davidson’s bespoke insurance plans and Sentry’s dependable track record makes it the leading choice for motorcycle insurance in the state.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Custom motorcycle coverage options
  • Endorsed by Sentry Insurance, known for financial stability and reliability
  • Provides discounts and rewards for safe riders and H.O.G. members
Drawbacks
  • Some riders may dislike third-party insurer coverage
  • More beneficial for Harley Davidson owners compared to other brands
  • Limited availability in specific areas

Best for Customer Service

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Satisfaction
9/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

In Indiana, Allstate is highly regarded for motorcycle insurance due to its outstanding customer service. Allstate’s personalized approach guarantees that every policyholder receives tailored assistance, which is vital for motorcyclists with specific needs different from standard auto insurance clients.

Allstate’s local agents are crucial for Indiana’s extensive biking community. They have a thorough understanding of the state’s road laws and biking habits, offering more than basic insurance advice. Additionally, Allstate’s digital platforms provide 24/7 access to manage policies and claims.

For motorcycle insurance in Indiana, Allstate stands out due to their knowledgeable local agents, effective digital tools, and dedication to customer satisfaction.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Extensive coverage options and customizable policies to suit individual requirements.
  • Access to local agents offering personalized service and knowledge of regional insurance needs.
  • A variety of discounts available, including those for safe riding and multiple policies.
Drawbacks
  • Premiums may be higher than some other insurance providers.
  • Discounts and policy options can vary widely based on personal circumstances.
  • Policies may be more suitable for casual rather than professional or competitive riders.

Best For Bundling Insurance

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Satisfaction
9/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Indiana motorcyclists looking to bundle their insurance, including motorcycle coverage, will find GEICO to be an excellent choice. Their competitive rates across multiple types of insurance make them a top pick for streamlining coverage.

What makes GEICO exceptional is its ability to integrate motorcycle, auto, and home insurance policies seamlessly into one package. This simplification of policy management often translates to considerable savings for policyholders.

GEICO is known for its cost-effectiveness and user-friendly experience. Their digital platforms, including a robust website and a highly-rated mobile app, make managing policies simple. Plus, GEICO’s customer service is highly ranked, ensuring efficient assistance for policyholders.

This gives Indiana motorcyclists easy access to policy details and hassle-free claims processing. GEICO’s mix of affordability, convenience, and dependable customer service makes it a great choice for bundling insurance in Indiana.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Offers competitive pricing and several discounts
  • User-friendly online tools and a mobile app for easy policy management.
  • Efficient claims processing with a strong reputation for customer service
Drawbacks
  • Coverage options might not be as specialized for motorcycles as those from providers focused solely on motorcycle insurance
  • Some customers report inconsistencies in customer service
  • Policy customization options may be more limited compared to specialized motorcycle insurance providers

Best for Military Members

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Satisfaction
8/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For those in the military, USAA is the leading choice for motorcycle insurance, providing customized services and a reliable partnership. Recognizing the specific needs of the military community, USAA has selected Progressive, an A+ (Superior) rated company, to manage coverage and claims. This partnership combines Progressive’s proven motorcycle insurance record with USAA’s commitment to military personnel and their families.

The alliance with Progressive guarantees USAA members specialized motorcycle insurance backed by financial strength and field expertise. Additionally, USAA’s distinction as the highest-rated customer service provider by J.D. Powers highlights its commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction.

This alliance benefits military members by providing streamlined services, efficient claims handling, and policies that address the nuances of military life. The cooperation between USAA and Progressive offers military riders a dependable and complete insurance solution tailored to their needs.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Services and discounts designed for military members and their families
  • Progressive, known for motorcycle insurance expertise, handles coverage and claims
  • USAA is renowned for customer service, ensuring a responsive and supportive experience
Drawbacks
  • Membership with USAA is exclusive to military members, veterans, and their families, restricting access for the general public
  • Some policyholders may prefer dealing directly with one insurer instead of through a partnership
  • Coverage options and benefits may be more generic as they are part of a larger insurance portfolio

Cheapest Minimum Liability Motorcycle Insurance Companies In Indiana

Our study found that USAA (Progressive) provides the least expensive minimum coverage in Indiana, with a monthly rate of $6.

“Cheapest minimum coverage for motorcycle insurance in Indiana” pertains to the most affordable policies that fulfill the state’s legal requirements for motorcycle riders. These generally include basic liability coverage for bodily injury and property damage caused by the rider in an accident.

Factors such as driving history greatly affect insurance rates in this category. Riders with clean records often receive lower premiums because insurers view them as less risky. In contrast, those with a history of accidents or violations typically see higher rates, as insurers consider them more likely to have future incidents.

Notably, experiencing an accident can greatly impact your insurance rate since it suggests a greater risk of costly claims for the insurance company. This assessment of risk directly influences the price of minimum coverage insurance in Indiana.

Insurance Provider Minimum Coverage Annual Cost (Paid in Full)
Progressive $84
Geico $86
Allstate $90
Dairyland $92
 

Cheapest Full Coverage Motorcycle Insurance In Indiana

After thorough research, we found that Harley-Davidson (Sentry) has the lowest-priced full coverage motorcycle insurance in Indiana, at a rate of $22 per month.

“Cheapest full coverage for motorcycle insurance in Indiana” denotes the most economical options for insurance policies that go beyond the state’s minimum liability requirements. Full coverage usually includes comprehensive and collision insurance, offering comprehensive protection against incidents such as accidents, theft, vandalism, and natural disasters.

Insurance rates in this category are heavily affected by a rider’s driving history. A clean record often leads to lower premiums because insurers perceive such riders as less risky.

In contrast, riders with a history of accidents or traffic violations often face higher rates due to being seen as higher risk by insurers. Being involved in an accident, specifically, can notably increase your rate as it heightens the insurer’s expectation of future claims.

Company Average Monthly Rate for Full Coverage
Harley-Davidson $22
Geico $25
Progressive $29
Allstate $34
Nationwide $37

Average Cost Of Motorcycle Insurance In Indiana

Full coverage motorcycle insurance in Indiana usually entails a monthly fee of $24.

Company Average Monthly Rate for Full Coverage
Harley-Davidson $22
Geico $25
Progressive $29
Allstate $34
Nationwide $37

Average Cost Of Motorcycle Insurance In Indiana – By City

Your rates for motorcycle insurance in Indiana will vary based on your city of residence. For instance, those living in big metropolitan areas tend to have higher rates compared to those in rural regions, due to a greater number of accidents in more populated zip codes.

These ten cities offer the lowest rates in Indiana for motorcycle insurance:

Rank City Average Monthly Rate
1 Fort Wayne $62
2 Bloomington $64
3 Lafayette $66
4 Fishers $68
5 Carmel $70
6 Muncie $72
7 Anderson $74
8 Terre Haute $76
9 South Bend $78
10 Evansville $80

How To Get A Motorcycle Insurance Quote

The steps to get a motorcycle insurance quote are simple and include:

Gather Your Personal Information: Gather your personal information before starting. This includes your full name, address, date of birth, and driver’s license number, along with details about any other riders who may use the motorcycle.

Collect Your Motorcycle’s Details: Ensure you have detailed information about your motorcycle ready, including the make, model, year, engine size, and vehicle identification number (VIN), before you begin. If you’ve made any modifications or have specific safety features, make sure to have those details handy, as they can influence your quote.

Determine Your Insurance Needs: Consider the type of coverage you need, including deciding on liability limits and whether you want additional options such as comprehensive, collision, or uninsured motorist coverage.

Research Insurance Providers: Look into insurance providers that offer motorcycle coverage, assessing their reputation, customer service performance, and financial health.

Get Quotes: Obtain quotes online, over the phone, or in person. Share the collected information with the insurance provider. Online forms are a quick and convenient method to get multiple quotes. (Insuranceopedia can give you multiple quotes, easing the selection process.)

Compare Quotes: After getting several quotes, evaluate them by looking at price, coverage options, deductibles, and any exclusions or limitations. Make sure you are comparing similar types of coverage across the quotes.

Ask About Discounts: Check with your insurance provider about any discounts you may be eligible for, such as safe driving, multiple policies, or motorcycle safety courses.

Review Quotes and Select a Policy: Examine all the information and select the policy that offers the most favorable combination of price and coverage for your needs.

Provide Additional Information and Make Your Purchase: After choosing a provider, you might need to provide extra information or documentation. Review the policy details, make your first payment, and receive your proof of insurance.

Remember, the cheapest quote doesn’t always offer the best value. Evaluate the coverage quality for the cost you’re paying.

 

Do You Need Motorcycle Insurance In Indiana?

Indiana mandates motorcycle insurance as a legal requirement. All motorcycle riders must have a minimum level of insurance coverage to legally ride on public roads. This law ensures that financial responsibility is upheld in the event of any damages or injuries resulting from an accident.

The state of Indiana requires minimum insurance coverage that includes liability insurance for injuries and property damage you may cause to others in an accident. The law requires at least $25,000 for injury/death to one person, $50,000 for injury/death to more than one person, and $25,000 for property damage. This basic coverage does not cover the rider’s own injuries or motorcycle damage.

To achieve broader protection, riders frequently add coverages like collision, comprehensive, and uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance. Collision coverage pays for accident-related motorcycle damages, while comprehensive covers non-collision incidents such as theft, vandalism, or natural disasters. Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage is vital in Indiana, where many drivers might be underinsured.

Though the law dictates minimum insurance coverage, it’s advisable for riders to assess their needs based on factors like the value of their motorcycle, how often they ride, and their financial situation. Moreover, not having the required insurance can lead to fines, suspension of your license, and motorcycle impoundment.

Our Methodology

To find the best motorcycle insurance in Indiana, I based my evaluation on objective information from AM Best for financial stability and J.D. Powers for customer satisfaction. I also drew on insights from multiple consumer review platforms and my experience as a former property and casualty insurance agent.

70

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

33

Brands Reviewed

35+

Research Hours

FAQs

How much is motorcycle insurance in Indiana?

The standard monthly cost for full coverage motorcycle insurance in Indiana is $24.

Who is the cheapest motorcycle insurance company in Indiana?

The least costly motorcycle insurance in Indiana is $22 per month from Harley Davidson, with Sentry Insurance Company responsible for coverage and policyholder service.

Do you need motorcycle insurance in Indiana?

Indiana requires by law that anyone riding a motorcycle must carry insurance.

Go back to top