Best Car Insurance For College Students In Illinois 2024
GEICO stands out as the best car insurance provider for college students in Illinois.
We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.
In the state of Illinois, the most common car accidents are rear-end collisions and angle accidents, which are attributed to driver error. Many of these car accidents, including fatalities, happen around university campuses, like Southern Illinois University.
With over 125 colleges and universities including special focus schools and religious institutions, it’s important that the hundreds of thousands of students who attend these institutions prepare themselves against potential car accidents by having the right auto coverage.
Best Car Insurance For College Students In Illinois, 2024
Compare Car Insurance For College Students In Illinois
Overall Rating | Best For | JD Power Rating | AM Best Rating | Get A Quote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Auto-Owners |
|
Customer Service |
837 |
A++ |
Instant Quote |
GEICO |
|
Affordable Coverage |
824 |
A++ |
Instant Quote |
State Farm |
|
Minimum Coverage |
842 |
A++ |
Instant Quote |
GEICO |
|
Full Coverage |
824 |
A++ |
Instant Quote |
State Farm |
|
Low-Mileage Drivers |
842 |
A++ |
Instant Quote |
Progressive |
|
Driving Violations |
853 |
A+ |
Instant Quote |
Best Car Insurance Companies For College Students In Illinois 2024
Best Minimum Coverage
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Students seeking minimum coverage should consider companies that have a reputation for supporting their policyholders. State Farm stands out for its personalized approach and affordable rates for young drivers.
State Farm is known for its efficient claims process and personalized customer service. Illinois college students should expect to spend about $1,512 on a minimum coverage policy from State Farm.
Opting for a minimum coverage policy can cut costs but might leave you at risk if an accident occurs. These low-cost plans only cover the state-required minimum insurance, which could result in out-of-pocket expenses for anything beyond that coverage.
Minimum coverage policies are a practical option for college students, providing the required insurance to drive legally and maintaining low costs.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Exceptional customer service team
- Cost-effective rates for most college student groups
- High rate of policy renewals
- Tailored policy management with a broad local insurance presence ✓
- Limited policy customization options compared to larger providers
- Does not offer gap insurance coverage ✘
Best Affordable Coverage
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅For college students purchasing auto insurance for the first time, cost is usually a top priority. GEICO offers young drivers both reliable coverage and an affordable rate of approximately $1,524 per year.
GEICO has been a top auto insurance provider for many years, continuing to offer some of the best rates and customer service in the industry. The company has also strengthened its digital capabilities with an intuitive mobile app and website that allow for easy account management and updates.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Best rates in the industry for college students
- Offers multiple discounts for students
- Mobile app and website focused on customer convenience
- Above-average satisfaction among customers ✓
- Limited local agent presence
- Missing gap and rideshare insurance coverage ✘
Best Full Coverage
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Since full coverage insurance costs more than minimum coverage, it’s important to select a provider like GEICO that offers competitive rates. Illinois college students generally pay approximately $2,104 per year for full coverage with GEICO.
GEICO isn’t just known for its affordable coverage; it also leads in technological advancements. Policyholders benefit from a website designed for easy and rapid updates to account information.
Students who commute or drive frequently for work should consider full coverage insurance over minimum coverage. Full coverage plans offer additional safeguards, including liability, comprehensive, and collision protection.
While full coverage policies deliver enhanced protection, they also incur higher costs. It’s essential to weigh the additional insurance benefits against the increased monthly premiums.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Provides accident forgiveness for policyholders
- Offers discounts through a usage-based program
- Affordable full coverage options for college students
- Customer satisfaction is above average ✓
- Lacks add-ons for new car replacement and rideshare insurance
- Bundle discounts aren’t as competitive as other providers
- Limited local agent presence ✘
Best For Motorists With Driving Violations
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Even though Progressive Insurance wasn’t the most affordable for standard coverage, it was the best choice for Illinois college students with driving violations. Whether due to a speeding ticket or an accident, Progressive still provided cost-effective insurance.
Most college students with driving violations spend approximately $1,572 each year on auto insurance coverage.
Progressive includes additional coverage options, like rideshare coverage, which is beneficial for college students working part-time with DoorDash or Lyft.
Monthly insurance premiums can rise significantly after a driving violation, no matter the driver’s age. College students, who are already considered high-risk, may face an even larger increase after an accident or ticket.
One way to soften the effects of a driving violation is to partner with a company like Progressive, which is known for insuring drivers with a history of tickets or accidents.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Offers rideshare add-on coverage
- Pays for vet expenses if your pet is injured in an accident and you carry collision insurance
- Affordable pricing for drivers with traffic violations ✓
- Customer service is about average
- Loyalty ratings from customers are below average ✘
Best Customer Service
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅If you’re a college student with questions about your auto insurance, you’re not alone. While many insurers offer apps and websites for support, Auto-Owners Insurance offers direct access to a live agent. This personal touch can make the slightly higher premium worthwhile.
The company not only delivers excellent customer service but also provides several discount options to lower expenses. College students can expect an annual cost of about $1,740 for coverage.
While it’s often thought that high-quality customer service means higher costs, this isn’t necessarily true, especially with car insurance providers in Illinois. Auto-Owners Insurance and State Farm both receive high marks for customer satisfaction and offer affordable plans for college students.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Known for delivering great customer service
- Emphasizes personal connections with local agents
- Flexible plans with various discount options
- Features accident forgiveness and decreasing deductibles ✓
- Restricted to 26 states
- No online tools for policy management
- Quotes are only available through agents ✘
Best For Low-Mileage Drivers
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Low-mileage policies and discounts can greatly reduce car insurance rates for college students. State Farm stands out for its affordability, with policies usually costing around $1,512 annually.
State Farm stands out for its excellent customer service and financial reliability, making it a solid choice for college students looking for their first auto insurance policy.
If you’re a college student who doesn’t plan to drive often while at school, you don’t need to spend more on insurance than necessary. You’ll still be required to have the state minimum coverage, but you can find discounts and affordable policies that match your low-mileage usage.
Insurance companies often offer discounts on low-mileage policies for drivers who keep their annual mileage under a set threshold. This threshold typically ranges from 7,500 to 10,000 miles per year, depending on the provider.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Low-mileage drivers can benefit from a generous usage-based discount program.
- Praised for its excellent customer service.
- Enjoys high rates of policyholder renewals and retention.
- Strong financial ratings from AM Best and other independent agencies. ✓
- Missing additional coverage for rideshare drivers and gap insurance.
- May be pricier for drivers with less-than-stellar credit. ✘
Average Cost Of Car Insurance For College Students In Illinois – By City
City | Average Annual Cost | Average Monthly Cost |
---|---|---|
Chicago | $2,880 | $240 |
Aurora | $2,305 | $192 |
Naperville | $2,220 | $185 |
Joliet | $2,388 | $199 |
Rockford | $2,172 | $181 |
Springfield | $2,112 | $176 |
Average Rates For 18 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
GEICO | $311 |
State Farm | $185 |
Allstate | $240 |
Auto-Owners | $146 |
Progressive | $270 |
Average Car Insurance Rates For 19 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
GEICO | $170 |
State Farm | $158 |
Travelers | $166 |
Auto-Owners | $130 |
Allstate | $201 |
Average Rates For 20 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
State Farm | $140 |
GEICO | $159 |
Travelers | $145 |
Progressive | $165 |
Auto-Owners | $120 |
Average Auto Insurance Rates For 21 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
Auto-Owners | $115 |
State Farm | $123 |
Travelers | $126 |
GEICO | $130 |
Progressive | $128 |
Average Rates For 22 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
State Farm | $126 |
Auto-Owners | $115 |
Progressive | $131 |
GEICO | $127 |
Allstate | $145 |
Average Rates For 23 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
GEICO | $115 |
State Farm | $102 |
Progressive | $117 |
Auto-Owners | $96 |
Allstate | $130 |
Average Rates For 24 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
State Farm | $93 |
Travelers | $105 |
GEICO | $98 |
Progressive | $100 |
Allstate | $116 |
Average Rates For 25 Year Old College Students In Illinois
Car Insurance Provider | Average Monthly Cost |
Allstate | $118 |
Travelers | $89 |
GEICO | $98 |
State Farm | $85 |
Progressive | $91 |
Average Cost Of Car Insurance On Family Policy vs. Individual Policy
Insurance Company | Individual Student Policy | Family Policy |
Auto-Owners | $115 | $106 |
State Farm | $123 | $101 |
Travelers | $126 | $120 |
GEICO | $130 | $130 |
Progressive | $128 | $130 |
How Can College Students Save Money On Car Insurance In Illinois
In Illinois, a 19-year-old driver will pay an average of $330 per month for a 6-month policy depending on the company. Progressive, Farmers, Allstate, and Nationwide are some of the most expensive in the state averaging closer to $400 per month but, there are several strategies that college students can use to make their car insurance premiums more budget friendly.
Used vs. New
While parents might often think that a new vehicle is a better investment in terms of overall cost, insurance companies think the opposite; a new vehicle in the hands of an inexperienced college driver means much higher premiums because of the anticipated cost of repairs and replacements.
Affiliation Discounts
College students in Illinois who participate in alumni organizations, honor societies, sororities, or fraternities can get insurance discounts from various providers. Membership materials for those organizations tend to have this information, but you can always ask your provider about it as well.
Student Discounts
Drivers in Illinois can get several types of student discounts based on things like good grades or students who are attending a non-local school and leaving their vehicle at home. This can save an average of $200 per year on a policy depending on the provider.
Security And Safety Improvements
Drivers of all ages, including college students, can get discounts on car insurance in Illinois by adding simple safety and security improvements from things like alarm systems to LoJack, as well as airbags and antilock brakes. Simple car alarms can reduce your premium by up to 5%.
Common Auto Insurance Claims In Illinois
In Illinois, there are several common auto insurance claims, including the following:
- Collisions where your vehicle collides with another object or vehicle, the most common of which are rear-end collisions
- Parking lot accidents
- Windshield damage
- Stolen catalytic converters
- Damage to a parked vehicle or theft of a parked vehicle
- Backup accidents
It is important to note that Illinois is a fault-based state and that means that whoever is found at fault for the accident is legally responsible for all of the damages.
Temporary Car Insurance
While temporary coverage isn’t available from all car insurance providers, it can be an ideal solution for college students who don’t plan to drive frequently.
Temporary auto insurance policies in Illinois usually cover a six-month period, with the flexibility to cancel when the term ends. This helps college students avoid paying for unneeded coverage while in school and is perfect for those studying abroad for a semester.
Do College Students Need Their Own Insurance, or Can They Stay On A Parent’s?
When you go to college, in most cases, it’s under the assumption that you will return home during breaks and in between each semester. As such, your parent’s home tends to remain your permanent residence. Even if you live somewhere on campus or near campus and you take your vehicle with you to school, having that vehicle and yourself be permanently addressed to your parents means you can stay on their policy.
Moving
However, if you move into your own home, and your vehicle is titled to yourself, and that becomes your permanent residence, then you will have to take out your own policy.
Marriage
Even if you are married, you and your spouse live with your parents, and the vehicles you drive are titled to yourself as well as your parents or just to your parents, you can remain on their policy.
However, if you own your vehicle or your spouse owns their vehicle you can decide whether you want to remain on the policy or take out your own.
Note: There is no age limit for how long you can remain on your parent’s policy as long as you keep their home as your permanent residence.
Try Usage-Based Car Insurance
Usage-based car insurance works much like telematics by tracking a driver’s behavior, but it also offers an additional feature that college students find especially appealing.
By driving less throughout the year, you can receive discounts and lower premiums with usage-based car insurance. These “Pay-Per-Mile” plans are a great way to find affordable coverage if your vehicle stays parked in the dorm lot or at home for much of the school year.
How To Get Discounts
Car insurance for college students in Illinois can be very expensive, especially for college students who have a history of at-fault accidents and citations. You can take advantage of carrier-provided discounts to try to lower your rates.
Be advised that every carrier has a different set of policy discounts and different percentages associated with those discounts. Before selecting your plan, explore things like the following:
- Paid in full discounts for paying annually instead of monthly
- Multi-vehicle for multiple vehicles under the same policy
- Multi-policy for college students who might want to combine things like renters insurance with their car insurance
- Military
- Student away
- Good student
- Safe driver
- Defensive driving
- Low mileage
- Accident-free
Telematics Car Insurance For College Students
Finding creative ways to save on car insurance is important for college students. Using telematics is one of the most effective ways to reduce your monthly premium.
Telematics are tools that insurance companies use to monitor your driving. The safer you drive, the better your rates, and the higher your chances of getting discounts for safe driving.
How To Buy Car Insurance As A College Student In Illinois
When you set out to buy car insurance as a college student in Illinois, especially if it’s your first policy, you can use platforms like Insuranceopedia to make the process more enjoyable.
Below are the steps to follow when using sites like this to compare rates from different providers:
- Figure out the type of coverage you need in your state and what the limits are.
- Determine whether you need things like comprehensive coverage in addition to your liability coverage or whether you can afford to add those extra coverage limits or car insurance products.
- Gather your personal information, including your driver’s history, driver’s license, and vehicle details.
- Set up your budget so you know how much you are comfortable paying in terms of your deductibles and how much you might have in savings in the event of an emergency.
From there, you can decide to compare policies online and purchase your policy online or do so through an agent either in person or on the phone. When you are doing this, be sure to ask about potential discounts as a college student.
Experts recommend that you compare quotes from at least three companies side by side with the same type of coverage information.
Once you purchase your new policy, you may have to let an old provider know that you are switching to a new company but if you are with the same company but taking out a new policy under your name instead of your parents, they will send you a replacement card.
When you are done, you will be provided with your insurance card from the insurance provider and that policy information must be presented when you register your vehicle or anytime you are involved in an accident or a traffic citation.
Note: If you do not have that card or you do not have coverage, you can have your registration suspended and face fines as well as reinstatement fees.
Minimum Car Insurance Requirements In Illinois
In Illinois, there are car insurance requirements known as 25/50/20, which refer to the following:
- $25,000 minimum for bodily injury coverage per person
- $50,000 minimum per accident
- $20,000 minimum in property damage coverage per accident
Drivers in Illinois must also carry a minimum of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for uninsured motorist coverage.
Once you take out a policy in Illinois your insurance provider will send you an insurance card that you must keep in your vehicle. If you don’t have that insurance card you cannot register your vehicle.
Our Methodology
To discover the lowest car insurance rates for college students in Illinois, we analyzed data from various car insurance review sites, including those that used rate information from public filings via Quadrant Information Services. Our team, with 25 years of collective insurance experience, also assessed each provider. Please note that while the rates provided in this guide are accurate, premiums can change from day to day and may vary depending on the driver.
Quotes Analyzed
Years Of Industry Experience
Brands Reviewed
Research Hours
FAQs
Who has the best car insurance for college students in Illinois?
While GEICO offers the most cost-effective coverage for college students, Progressive and State Farm are also worth looking into based on your driving history and coverage requirements in Illinois.
Do college students need car insurance in Illinois?
Illinois law requires all drivers to have car insurance. College students can either stay covered under their parents’ policy while residing at home or obtain their own insurance when they move out.
Is car insurance more expensive for college students in Illinois?
For younger drivers in Illinois, car insurance is typically more costly. College students often have better rates than 16-year-olds but still pay significantly more than 25-year-olds.
How can you add a college student to a family policy?
If you’re planning to add a college student to your family insurance plan, you should consult with your insurance provider before the student heads off to college. Most carriers will require the student’s new zip code and confirmation that their main address is still the family home. There could be additional requirements for students studying out-of-state.
Can you stay on your parents’ car insurance if you move out?
While you’re still living with your parents, you can benefit from staying on their car insurance policy. However, once you move out and get a new permanent address, you will no longer be able to stay on their auto policy.
Sources
⇅- ILSOS – Mandatory vehicle insurance
- University Of Illinois Urbana-Champaign – How to save on a car if you are an Illinois student
- IDOI – Auto insurance definitions
- Allstate – Car insurance discounts for college & teen drivers