Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Erie, PA

For drivers in Erie, Erie Insurance offers the cheapest minimum coverage, with an average monthly rate of $57.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 12 March 2025
Written by Doug Schaffer
On this page Open

Looking for the cheapest car insurance in Erie, PA? Be prepared for a wide range of pricing.

If affordability is key, Erie has the cheapest liability-only coverage. State Farm is the best bet for full coverage savings, while National General offers young drivers the lowest premiums.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Erie, PA 2025

Cheapest Liability-only Car Insurance In Erie: Erie

Erie provides Erie’s most budget-friendly minimum car insurance, with a typical rate of $57 per month.

The following table outlines rate comparisons for different insurance providers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie $57 $684
National General $68 $816
GEICO $76 $912
Allstate $88 $1,056
Nationwide $98 $1,176

Cheapest Full Coverage Insurance Rates In Erie: State Farm

State Farm has the best rates for full coverage car insurance in Erie, charging an average of $106 per month.

Here’s a table that compares average auto insurance quotes from inexpensive insurers in Erie.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
State Farm $106 $1,272
Erie $122 $1,464
GEICO $158 $1,896
Auto-Owners $134 $1,608
Travelers $158 $1,896

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates For Seniors: State Farm

For seniors in Erie, State Farm provides the best car insurance rates, with an average monthly premium of $67.

The table below compares the lowest auto insurance quotes available for senior drivers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
State Farm $67 $804
Clearcover $74 $888
SafeAuto $75 $900
Erie $76 $912
Auto-Owners $78 4936

Cheapest Rates In Erie For Teenagers: State Farm

The best rates for teenage drivers in Erie come from State Farm, where the average monthly premium is $126.

The table below showcases which insurers have the lowest rates for teenage car insurance.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
State Farm $126 $1,512
Penn National $135 $1,620
SafeAuto $131 $1,572
Allied $142 $1,704
Erie $139 $1,668

Cheapest Auto Insurance For Young Adults in Erie: National General

Young adults in Erie can secure the cheapest car insurance with National General, which offers average monthly premiums of $88.

Take a look at the table below to compare affordable insurance rates for young adult drivers in Erie.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
National General $88 $1,056
Jupiter Auto $90 $1,080
State Farm $126 $1,512
Clearcover $92 $1,104
Penn National $112 $1,344

Cheapest Car Insurance In Erie For Good Drivers: Erie

At just $57 per month on average, Erie provides the cheapest car insurance for safe drivers in Erie.

If you maintain a clean driving record, check the table below for the lowest insurance quotes available.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie $57 $684
National General $68 $816
GEICO $76 $912
Allstate $88 $1,056
Nationwide $98 $1,176

Find affordable Erie rates

Free. Secure. No Spam.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Erie After A Speeding Ticket: Erie

Erie drivers with a speeding ticket can secure cheaper insurance from Erie, with rates averaging $151 per month.

Compare the table below to find out what drivers with a speeding ticket typically pay for car insurance.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie $151 $1,812
GEICO $189 $2,268
Auto-Owners $162 $1,944
Travelers $190 $2,280
Allstate $215 $2,580

Cheapest For Drivers With After At-Fault Accident: Erie

Erie has the best rates for drivers with an at-fault accident, with an average monthly premium of $160.

Below, you’ll find the insurers with the cheapest car insurance for drivers who have been responsible for an accident.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie $150 $1,800
GEICO $200 $2,400
Auto-Owners $173 $2,076
Progressive $209 $2,508
Allstate $229 $2,748

Cheapest Rates In Erie For Drivers After A DUI: Erie

Erie drivers with a DUI can secure the cheapest car insurance from Erie, with rates around $88 per month.

The lowest car insurance rates for DUI drivers in Erie are listed in the table below.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie $88 $1,056
Allstate $277 $3,324
Travelers $243 $2,916
Auto-Owners $207 $2,484
GEICO $244 $2,928

Best Car Insurance Companies In Erie

AAA offers the lowest insurance rates in Erie at $57 per month, but Auto-Owners and National General follow closely with rates of $62 and $68, respectively.

Below is a comparison of the top 10 car insurance providers in Erie, PA, arranged by their average monthly prices.

Company Monthly Premium
Erie $57
National General $68
GEICO $76
Allstate $88
Nationwide $98
Auto-Owners $62
Direct Auto $93
Travelers $75
Foremost $94
Safeco $99

Average Auto Insurance Rates In Erie – By Age

Insurance rates are largely influenced by age. Since younger drivers have less experience and a greater chance of accidents, they often pay more. Teens generally spend about $3,481 per year on auto insurance.

A clean driving history can lead to lower insurance rates once a driver turns 25.

Drivers in their 50s and early 60s usually benefit from lower insurance rates, as companies use age to measure driving risk and experience.

Age Average Yearly Rate
Teenagers $3,481
20s $2,074
30s $1,391
40s $1,073
50s $1,073
60s $1,121
70s $1,574

Average Rates In Erie – By Vehicle

The type of car you own affects your insurance rate, as insurers consider factors like make, model, and year. High-end and newer vehicles with advanced features usually lead to pricier premiums.

The table below breaks down the average insurance costs for different types of vehicles in Erie.

Vehicle Average Monthly Rate
Honda CrV $91
Ford Ranger $109
Honda Accord $275
GMC Terrain $437
Mazda 5 $137

Average Cost Of Auto Insurance In Erie – By Zip Code

Crime rates differ by zip code, so insurers adjust car insurance premiums accordingly.

The table below breaks down the average insurance costs for different Erie zip codes.

City Average Monthly Rate
16507 $146
16509 $127
16511 $120
16504 $113
16512 $70

How Much Is Car Insurance In Other Cities in Pennsylvania?

Location is a key factor in car insurance pricing. Areas with high accident, theft, and vandalism rates—especially cities—often come with higher insurance costs.

In Valley Forge, the typical car insurance rate is around $73 per month, but in Philadelphia, it’s only $236 per month.

City Average Monthly Rate
Pittsburgh $144
Bethlehem $147
Johnstown $109
Wilkes Barre $124
Valley Forge $73
Philadelphia $236
Lancaster $133
Harrisburg $134
Scranton $134
Allentown $157

Find affordable Erie rates

Free. Secure. No Spam.

Our Methodology

My analysis of Erie, PA car insurance companies is based on factors like customer service, product selection, pricing, and user reviews.

107

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

31

Brands Reviewed

30+

Research Hours

FAQs

Who has the lowest car insurance rates in Erie?

The lowest car insurance prices in Erie come from Erie for minimum coverage and State Farm for full coverage, which includes both comprehensive and collision insurance.

What is the average cost of car insurance in Erie?

The cost of car insurance in Erie averages $130 per month, but your actual rate will depend on your zip code, car details, and driving record.

Go back to top