Best Car Insurance For College Students In Colorado 2024

I consider GEICO the leading car insurance provider for college students in Colorado. Colorado college students looking for minimum coverage or exceptional customer service will find State Farm to be a strong option. Progressive, however, was the top pick for drivers with a history of accidents and violations.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 01 November 2024
Written by Doug Schaffer
On this page Open

Colorado is in the top five most expensive states for car insurance, and this rate increases for college drivers, who can expect to pay higher premiums than those in their mid-twenties.

Colorado College drivers have contributed to a surge in fatalities of 53% year-over-year with the Colorado Department of Transportation urging teenagers to be safer, understand the risks and dangers of driving, and find ways to improve driver behavior, reduce risk, and save on car insurance.

Best Car Insurance For College Students In Colorado, 2024

Car Insurance For College Students, Colorado, 2024

Compare The Best Car Insurance For College Students In Colorado

Overall Rating Best For JD Power Rating AM Best Rating Get A Quote
GEICO
4.7

Affordable Coverage

824

A++

Instant Quote
Progressive
4.6

Driving Violations

853

A+

Instant Quote
GEICO
4.7

Full Coverage

824

A++

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Minimum Coverage

842

A++

Instant Quote
Auto-Owners
4.6

Customer Service

837

A++

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Low-Mileage Drivers

842

A++

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Car Insurance Companies For College Students In Colorado 2024


Best For Low-Mileage Drivers

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Significant reductions in car insurance costs for college students can be achieved through low-mileage policies and discounts. State Farm offers the most affordable rates, with annual premiums usually around $2,658.

State Farm’s excellence in customer service and financial stability makes it a reliable option for college students who are looking for their first auto insurance policy.

If you’re a college student and don’t plan on driving much, there’s no need to pay for more insurance than required. The state minimum coverage is still necessary, but there are discounts and affordable policies available that fit your low-mileage situation.

Low-mileage policies often include discounted rates for drivers who stay below a specified annual mileage. The mileage limit varies by insurance company but is generally between 7,500 and 10,000 miles per year.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Provides a generous discount for drivers with low mileage through a usage-based program.
  • Known for excellent customer service.
  • High renewal and retention rates among policyholders.
  • Holds strong financial ratings from independent agencies such as AM Best.
Drawbacks
  • Lacks rideshare and gap insurance coverage options.
  • May be more expensive for drivers with poor credit.

Best Affordable Coverage

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Affordability is typically a top concern for college students buying their first auto insurance. GEICO provides young drivers with coverage that costs roughly $1,453 per year, along with the reliability of a well-known company.

Over the past several decades, GEICO has established itself as a top auto insurance provider, offering industry-leading rates and excellent customer service. The company has also expanded its digital presence with a mobile app and website designed for easy account management.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Best-in-class rates for college students
  • Offers discounts tailored to students
  • Convenient mobile app and website for managing policies
  • Customer satisfaction scores are higher than average
Drawbacks
  • Limited local agent availability
  • No coverage for gap and rideshare insurance

Best Minimum Coverage

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

College students looking for minimum coverage should choose an insurer with a reputation for excellent policyholder support. State Farm offers personalized service and some of the lowest rates available for young drivers.

State Farm’s quick claims process and personalized customer service help resolve issues efficiently. Colorado college students can expect to pay approximately $2,212 for a minimum coverage policy through State Farm.

Opting for minimum coverage can reduce your overall insurance costs but may leave you at risk if you’re in an accident. These low-cost policies cover only the minimum insurance required by law, meaning any additional expenses would come out of your pocket.

College students benefit from minimum coverage policies as they provide the required insurance to drive legally and keep overall costs low.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Premier customer service team
  • Competitive pricing for a wide range of college students
  • High rate of renewals for policies
  • Personalized policy management with an extensive local presence
Drawbacks
  • Policies are less customizable compared to other leading insurers
  • Gap insurance coverage is not available

Best Full Coverage

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Given that full coverage insurance is more expensive than minimum coverage, picking a company like GEICO with affordable rates is crucial. Colorado college students generally spend around $2,602 annually for full coverage with GEICO.

GEICO isn’t just about providing affordable coverage; it also excels in innovation. Their website is designed for ease of use, allowing policyholders to change their account information quickly.

Students who frequently drive to campus or use their vehicle for work should look into full coverage insurance as opposed to minimum coverage. Full coverage provides extra protection, including liability, comprehensive, and collision.

Full coverage insurance offers more protection, but it is more expensive. It’s important to weigh the value of the extra coverage against the additional monthly costs.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Accident forgiveness included in policies
  • Usage-based program provides discount options
  • Affordable full coverage rates for college students
  • Customer satisfaction scores are above average
Drawbacks
  • No options for new car replacement or rideshare insurance add-ons
  • Bundle discount rates are lower than some competitors
  • Limited availability of local agents

Best Customer Service

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Payouts
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

If you’re a college student with questions about auto insurance, it’s common to seek help. Many insurers offer interactive apps and websites, but Auto-Owners Insurance also connects you with a live person. This personal assistance can make the slightly higher premium worthwhile.

The company not only excels in customer service but also provides various discounts to further reduce expenses. College students can anticipate paying around $4,329 annually for their coverage.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Focuses on relationships with local, live agents
  • Offers flexible coverage with a range of discounts
  • Includes accident forgiveness and lowering deductibles
  • Renowned for its great customer service
Drawbacks
  • Only offered in 26 states
  • Quotes need to be requested from agents
  • No online management for policies

Best For Motorists With Driving Violations

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Although Progressive Insurance wasn’t the cheapest for standard coverage, it was the top pick for Colorado college students with driving violations. Whether due to a speeding ticket or an accident, Progressive still provided affordable coverage.

College students with driving violations generally pay around $4,697 a year for auto insurance coverage.

Progressive’s additional coverage options include rideshare coverage, which benefits college students who drive part-time for DoorDash or Lyft.

Monthly insurance costs can rise considerably after a traffic violation, regardless of the driver’s age. College students, with their high-risk status, might experience an even bigger rate increase after an accident or ticket.

One effective way to mitigate the impact of a driving violation is to work with a company like Progressive, known for insuring drivers who have a history of tickets or accidents.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Covers vet bills for your pet if injured in an accident and you have collision coverage
  • Rideshare coverage available as an add-on
  • Competitive pricing for motorists with driving violations
Drawbacks
  • Below-average ratings for customer loyalty
  • Customer service is rated average

Average Car Insurance Rates For College Students In Colorado – By City

City Average Annual Cost Average Monthly Cost
Denver $2,904 $242
Colorado Springs $2,880 $240
Aurora $3,000 $250
Fort Collins $2,304 $192
Boulder $2,472 $206

Average Rates For 18 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
GEICO $334
State Farm $275
Nationwide $399
Auto-Owners $282
Progressive $585

Average Rates For 19 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
Allstate $206
State Farm $242
GEICO $186
Auto-Owners $248
Progressive $273

Average Rates For 20 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $214
GEICO $166
Progressive $246
Allstate $184
Auto-Owners $216

Car Insurance Rates For 21 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
GEICO $121
State Farm $184
Auto-Owners $191
Allstate $157
Progressive $195

Average Rates For 22 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $168
GEICO $110
Progressive $179
Nationwide $181
Allstate $144

Insurance Rates For 23 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
GEICO $89
Kemper $202
Progressive $167
State Farm $150
Allstate $140

Rates For 24 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $138
Farmers $139
Auto-Owners $142
Progressive $155
Allstate $135

Car Insurance Rates For 25 Year Old College Students In Colorado

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $81
Progressive $136
Auto-Owners $130
Farmers $149
Allstate $131

Cheap Rates For College Student On Family Policy vs. Individual Policy

Insurance Company Individual Student Policy Family Policy
State Farm $168 $155
GEICO $110 $110
Progressive $179 $178
Nationwide $181 $181
Allstate $144 $144

How Can College Students Save Money On Car Insurance In Colorado

For most college students, car insurance premiums in Colorado are significantly more expensive than any other age group and whether or not you remain on a parent policy or take out your own, you’ll need to be able to cut those costs. Thankfully there are several avenues available to you.

Affiliation Discounts

Depending on your auto insurance provider, belonging to a sorority, fraternity, honor society, or other club can result in lower premiums. Alumni associations can, too.

Used vs. New

Considering a new car is a gift for your college student? Think again. Car insurance providers set the policy based on vehicle risk, repair costs, and rates of car theft in the Colorado area. This means cheaper vehicles and older vehicles are less likely to be stolen and much cheaper to repair in the event of an accident.

Student Discounts

Some of the best potential discounts for college students, whether they are on a parent policy or an individual policy, apply to grades; those who stay on the honor roll or Dean’s list or keep a high GPA can get substantial discounts from various providers.

Other discounts can apply to college students who go to college more than 100 miles away from their permanent residence and don’t take their car with them or have a safe driving record.

Installing Security And Safety Improvements

In Colorado, some of the biggest causes of accidents involving college students involve distracted driving, drowsy driving, driving under the influence, speeding, and road conditions.

Research at the University of Colorado Boulder indicates that fatal car accidents for college-age drivers increase during daylight savings.

Why? Drivers miss out on sleep and end up driving while drowsy or in the dark when road conditions are not as favorable and visibility is limited.

Security and safety features can help reduce the risk of accidents because of these risk factors like better daytime running lights to increase visibility no matter the road conditions, airbags to reduce the risk of personal injury in the event of an accident, and anti-lock brakes to help when speeding results in quickly slamming on your brakes.

  • Installing daytime running lights can earn discounts of 3% on average.
  • Airbags can save up to 23% to 30% on the medical payments or personal injury portion of a plan.

These rates will vary depending on the insurance provider you have but can often be combined with other discounts for college students.

Do College Students Need Their Own Insurance, or Can They Stay On A Parent’s?

Colorado requires all drivers to maintain auto insurance and keep proof of that insurance when driving or parking on any public roadways. But does that mean that college students need their own policy?

Home

Where a college student calls “home” is generally the biggest factor in determining whether a student can stay on their parent’s insurance policy or need their own policy.

If a permanent residence is maintained at a parent’s home, college students in Colorado can remain on the insurance policy for a parent or a guardian. This applies to any students who go to college and are living in student housing or college dorms but still keep their permanent residents that of their parents. Utilizing this option can significantly reduce the cost of insurance.

However, once an individual moves out and they keep their car at their primary residence somewhere other than a parent’s home, then they have to get their own policy.

Note: Students who maintain a permanent residence at their parent’s house but temporarily live in a college dorm or student housing and park their car in an associated garage or parking lot can still stay on a parent policy.

Common Auto Insurance Claims In Colorado

The four typical types of auto insurance claims in Colorado are generally:

  • Comprehensive Claims (2.81 claims for every 100 vehicles per year)
  • Collision Claims (5.8 claims for every 100 vehicles per year)
  • Property Damage Claims (3.36 claims for every 100 vehicles per year)
  • Bodily Injury Claims (0.95 claims for every 100 vehicles per year)

In Colorado, some of the most common auto insurance claims are bodily injury for those who get involved in accidents, as well as property damage from crashes at intersections and rear-end collisions.

Temporary Car Insurance

Although some car insurance providers don’t offer temporary coverage, it’s a good option for college students who won’t be driving often.

Typically, temporary auto insurance offers six months of coverage, with the ability to cancel once the term ends. This is ideal for college students who don’t need insurance while at school and for those planning to study abroad for a semester.

How To Buy Car Insurance As A College Student In Colorado

Platforms like Insuranceopedia simplify the process of purchasing your first insurance policy. With these sites you can compare costs, deductibles, and premiums from several companies at once.

It is recommended that you compare quotes from at least three providers before selecting your new insurance policy.

Note: You can use online platforms to compare policies and discounts and then purchase your policy either online or via an agent in person.

Follow these steps to make the process easier:

  1. Make sure to have all important information ready, such as your vehicle info, license numbers, policyholder details, and driving history.
  2. Identify the insurance coverage required to comply with Colorado law and whether you want additional coverage or higher coverage limits.
  3. Make a personal budget so you know how much you can afford in premiums and deductibles, and whether you can take advantage of things like annual instead of monthly premiums at a discount.

If you are taking out a new policy, be sure to inform your old provider.

Telematics Car Insurance For College Students

College students need to get creative with car insurance savings, and telematics is one of the most efficient ways to reduce your monthly premium.

Telematics devices are employed by insurance companies to monitor your driving behavior. Safer driving results in better rates and increases your likelihood of receiving safe driver discounts.

How To Get Discounts

College students, especially those with any history of at-fault accidents or tickets, might not know how to find car insurance discounts. Thankfully, insurance companies make it relatively easy.

  • If you already have an insurance provider and want to keep the policy you have, you can look online through your insurance portal and compare different discounts based on your circumstances. You can also call your insurance providers directly to ask what discounts they might have that could be applied toward your policy.
  • If you are interested in applying discounts from things like affiliate groups, you can see what they might offer through their websites or through their points of contact and then apply those to your policy.
  • If you are considering a new provider, you can check online or in person with different providers about the types of discounts they might offer for taking out a new policy.

Remember that there are several types of potential discounts depending on your carrier from things like discounts awarded to paying insurance premiums annually instead of monthly, discounts for military service, safe driver discounts, and discounts for driving a limited number of miles each year.

Try Usage-Based Car Insurance

Similar to telematics, usage-based car insurance monitors a driver’s actions on the road, but it also offers an added component that’s especially appealing to college students.

With usage-based car insurance, driving less each year can result in discounts and reduced premiums. These “Pay-Per-Mile” plans are a cost-effective way to get affordable coverage if your vehicle stays in the dorm lot or at home for the majority of the school year.

Colorado Car Insurance Laws

Colorado laws prohibit insurance companies from using external consumer data or information to discriminate against customers when approving policies or setting policy premiums.

Insurance coverage requires liability insurance with a minimum of $25,000 for bodily injury or death to any one person, $50,000 for bodily injury to all involved people, and $15,000 for property damage.

Conviction in Colorado of certain traffic offenses can result in driving privileges being suspended or revoked as well as a requirement to carry SR-22 insurance.

Collision coverage is not required in Colorado but if you purchased your car with a loan, it is very likely that your bank will require it as part of your lender agreement.

Failure to maintain the right insurance coverage or driving without proof of insurance can result in penalties of up to 40 hours in community service, license suspension until insurance is proven, a fine of at least $500, and four points added to your license.

Our Methodology

We analyzed information from numerous car insurance review sites to identify the most affordable rates for college students in Colorado, with some sites using public rate filings from Quadrant Information Services. Additionally, our team applied its combined 25 years of insurance experience to evaluate each provider. It’s important to keep in mind that, even though the rates in this guide are accurate, premiums can fluctuate daily and vary for each individual driver.

278

Quotes Analyzed

25

Years Of Industry Experience

22

Brands Reviewed

38+

Research Hours

FAQs

Who has the best car insurance for college students in Colorado?

GEICO is known for offering the most affordable car insurance for college students. Nonetheless, depending on your driving history and desired coverage, it’s also wise to consider Progressive and State Farm in Colorado.

Do college students need car insurance in Colorado?

In Colorado, car insurance is required for all drivers. College students can either remain on their parents’ policy while living at home or purchase their own insurance when they move.

Is car insurance more expensive for college students in Colorado?

Car insurance rates are usually higher for younger drivers in Colorado. While college students often receive better rates than 16-year-olds, their premiums are still notably higher than those for 25-year-olds.

How can you add a college student to a family policy?

Before you add a college student to your family insurance plan, consult with your insurance provider before the student starts their college term. Most insurers will need the student’s updated zip code and to verify that their primary address is still the family home. Additional requirements may apply for students who are attending school out-of-state.

Can you stay on your parents’ car insurance if you move out?

As a college student, you can benefit from staying on your parents’ car insurance as long as you live with them. However, once you move out and have a new permanent address, you will need to switch to your own auto insurance.

Go back to top