Best Car Insurance For College Students In Pennsylvania 2024

GEICO is the car insurance company I’d recommend to college students in Pennsylvania. State Farm excelled for Pennsylvania college students seeking minimum coverage policies or outstanding customer service, while Progressive was the preferred choice for those with accidents or violations on their driving records.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 09 November 2024
Written by Doug Schaffer
On this page Open

Pennsylvania has some of the highest numbers of educational institutions, with nearly 300 colleges, universities, and technical institutions, including 14 public universities.

However, college students in Pennsylvania face increasingly higher car insurance rates compared to drivers in their mid to late twenties, in large part because Pennsylvania has some of the highest School crash zone rates around the country. While it is said that cars typically slow down when they are near college campuses in Pennsylvania, many roads around campuses are dark, particularly in Winter, and limited lighting and lack of sidewalks can make it dangerous.

Moreover, college students in Pennsylvania are more likely to speed, be distracted, not wear a seatbelt, and drive recklessly. For this reason, car insurance rates are much more expensive for younger college students, but there are things that can be done to bring them down.

Best Car Insurance For College Students In Pennsylvania, 2024

Best Car Insurance For College Students, Pennsylvania, 2024

Compare Car Insurance For College Students In Pennsylvania

Overall Rating Best For JD Power Rating AM Best Rating Get A Quote
GEICO
4.7

Affordable Coverage

824

A++

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Minimum Coverage

842

A++

Instant Quote
Auto-Owners
4.6

Customer Service

837

A++

Instant Quote
GEICO
4.7

Full Coverage

824

A++

Instant Quote
Progressive
4.6

Driving Violations

853

A+

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Low-Mileage Drivers

842

A++

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Car Insurance For College Students In Pennsylvania 2024


Best Affordable Coverage

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

College students often look for affordable options when purchasing their first auto insurance. GEICO offers both a reasonable annual rate of about $1,350 and the backing of a reputable insurer.

GEICO has long been one of the top auto insurance providers, known for delivering great rates and outstanding customer service. The company has also heavily invested in its digital presence, providing a mobile app and website that simplify account management and updates.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Leading rates for college students in the industry
  • Several discounts specifically for students
  • Easy-to-manage policies via mobile app and website
  • Customer satisfaction scores are above average
Drawbacks
  • Sparse local agent presence
  • Lacks gap and rideshare insurance options

Best Minimum Coverage

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Students who are opting for minimum coverage should select a company that is known for backing its policyholders. State Farm offers a personalized service and some of the most affordable rates for young drivers.

State Farm resolves issues quickly with its efficient claims process and offers individual customer service. For a minimum coverage policy, Pennsylvania college students can expect to spend around $1,406.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Industry-leading team for customer support
  • Affordable rates for most college student categories
  • High rate of policy renewals
  • Customized approach to policy management with a large local agent network
Drawbacks
  • Policies are less flexible than those from other major providers
  • Gap insurance coverage is not offered

Best Full Coverage

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Since full coverage insurance is more costly than minimum coverage, it’s wise to choose a company like GEICO known for its competitive rates. On average, Pennsylvania college students pay approximately $3,602 per year for full coverage with GEICO.

In addition to its affordable coverage, GEICO is recognized for its innovative approach. Their website provides a user-friendly experience, enabling policyholders to update their account details in seconds.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Offers accident forgiveness as a policy feature
  • Discount opportunities with a usage-based program
  • Competitive full coverage rates for college students
  • Higher-than-average customer satisfaction
Drawbacks
  • No add-ons for new car replacement or rideshare insurance
  • Bundle discounts aren’t as high as those from competitors
  • Limited local agent presence

Best Customer Service

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Payouts
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

It’s natural for college students to have queries about their auto insurance policies. While many insurers have apps and websites for support, Auto-Owners Insurance offers the added benefit of speaking with a live agent. The extra support can justify the slightly higher premium.

In addition to offering great customer service, the company has several discount options to help lower your insurance costs. College students can expect to pay about $4,329 per year for coverage.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Places importance on connections with local agents
  • Known for top-tier customer service
  • Provides accident forgiveness and a reducing deductible
  • Offers flexible coverage options and discounts
Drawbacks
  • Restricted to 26 states
  • No online tools for policy management
  • Quotes are agent-exclusive

Best For Low-Mileage Drivers

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Low-mileage policies and discounts can help college students cut their car insurance expenses significantly. State Farm is known for offering the most affordable plans, with annual costs typically around $2,658.

College students considering their first auto insurance policy can rely on State Farm, which scores highly for both customer service and financial stability.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Low-mileage drivers benefit from a generous usage-based discount program.
  • Exceptional customer service experience.
  • Boasts high rates of policyholder renewal and retention.
  • Strong financial ratings from independent agencies like AM Best.
Drawbacks
  • Does not offer additional coverage for rideshare and gap insurance.
  • May be more costly for drivers with lower credit scores.

Best For Motorists With Driving Violations

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

While Progressive Insurance didn’t offer the most affordable rates for standard coverage, they were the best choice for Pennsylvania college students with driving violations. Whether dealing with a speeding ticket or an accident, Progressive still offered reasonably priced coverage.

On average, college students with driving violations are paying about $4,697 annually for auto insurance.

One of Progressive’s additional coverage options is rideshare coverage, perfect for college students working part-time with DoorDash or Lyft.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Offers rideshare add-ons
  • Budget-friendly rates for drivers with traffic violations
  • Includes vet expenses for your pet if injured in an accident, with collision insurance
Drawbacks
  • Average customer service experience
  • Customer loyalty ratings fall below average

Cheapest Overall Rates For College Students In Pennsylvania

College students can find the most affordable rates from Allstate, who offer annual premiums of $1,350.

Company Average Rate Per Year
Allstate $1,350
State Farm $1,406
Progressive $3,016
Travelers $967
GEICO $2,046

Average Cost For College Students In Pennsylvania – By City

City Average Annual Cost Average Monthly Cost
Philadelphia $3,480 $290
Pittsburgh $1,968 $164
Allentown $2,112 $176
Erie $1,908 $159
Scranton $1,956 $163

Average Rates For 18 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
GEICO $254
State Farm $199
Travelers $158
Allstate $257
Progressive $480

Average Rates For 19 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
Allstate $184
State Farm $175
Travelers $128
GEICO $211
Nationwide $156

Average Rates For 20 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $155
GEICO $197
Travelers $114
Allstate $157
Nationwide $133

Average Rates For 21 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
GEICO $180
Auto-Owners $111
Travelers $89
State Farm $129
Progressive $289

Average Rates For 22 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
Allstate $113
State Farm $117
Progressive $251
Travelers $81
GEICO $171

Average Rates For 23 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
Travelers $74
State Farm $104
Progressive $217
Nationwide $83
Allstate $108

Average Rates For 24 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $96
Allstate $103
GEICO $155
Travelers $70
Progressive $198

Average Rates For 25 Year Old College Students In Pennsylvania

Car Insurance Provider Average Monthly Cost
State Farm $80
Travelers $64
Allstate $98
GEICO $150
Progressive $167

Average Cost Of Car Insurance On Family Policy vs. Individual Policy

Insurance Company Individual Student Policy Family Policy
GEICO $180 $170
Auto-Owners $111 $105
Travelers $89 $117
State Farm $129 $122
Progressive $289 $251

Find Affordable Car Insurance Today

Free. Secure. No Spam.

How Can College Students Save Money On Car Insurance In Pennsylvania

If you are looking for ways to bring down your college insurance, and staying on a parent or guardian policy isn’t possible, you can utilize the strategies below.

Affiliation Discounts

Membership in one of 500 different groups can get you a discount with companies like Geico. Other providers offer discounts for being part of sororities, fraternities, or other societies on campus.

Even after graduation you can continue to take advantage of these types of affiliation discounts from your car insurance provider through things like alumni associations.

Security And Safety Improvements

There are several vehicle security and safety improvements that can be made to a new or used vehicle which offer substantial discounts for college students in Pennsylvania.

  1. Installing things like anti-theft systems can average discounts of up to 25% from providers across the state.
  2. Anti-lock brakes can get you a discount averaging between 5% and 10% in Pennsylvania.
  3. If your vehicle has airbags, the personal injury portion of your car insurance could drop by an average of 20%.

Used vs. New

Before purchasing a brand new car consider the fact that new cars that are financed might require you to take out extra coverage, and will cost more because of the increased repair costs. While you might get better gas mileage, as a young driver, with higher risk of accidents, a used vehicle is a better investment for those looking to reduce their car insurance costs in Pennsylvania.

Military

Military personnel who are members of the Reserves or National Guard, or active duty can be eligible for up to 15% on average from several companies operating in Pennsylvania.

Student Discounts

In Pennsylvania, companies like Geico can give you up to 15% off your coverage if you are a full-time student with a good academic record.

You can also get a discount for completing a driver’s education course. Being accident-free for 5 years with the same company can save you up to 22%.

Do College Students Need Their Own Insurance, or Can They Stay On A Parent’s?

In Pennsylvania, college students, where possible, tend to stay on their parent’s car insurance policy, especially if they live at home or drive their parent’s car, but this is not a requirement one way or the other.

Students are allowed to remain on a parent’s policy as long as that home is listed as their primary residence. Even students who attend college out of state maintain their parents’ home as their permanent residence and, therefore, qualify.

There is no age limit in Pennsylvania for remaining on a parent’s car insurance policy so long as the primary residence aspect is met.

However, if a student owns their own vehicle and it is not owned by the parent or a student permanently moves out, then they will likely need to purchase their own insurance policy.

Common Auto Insurance Claims In Pennsylvania

Auto insurance claims in Pennsylvania generally fit into four common categories, such as:

  • Collision Claims (5.8 claims per 100 years of vehicle operation)
  • Comprehensive Claims (2.81 claims per 100 years of vehicle operation)
  • Bodily Injury Claims (0.95 claims per 100 years of vehicle operation)
  • Property Damage Claims (3.36 claims per 100 years of vehicle operation)

In Pennsylvania, the two most common claims are for property damage and bad faith insurance claims. Property damage claims happen when you cause damage to the property of another driver and have to submit a claim to cover those costs and bad faith claims happen when your insurance company denies some of your coverage and you try to fight it.

Try Usage-Based Car Insurance

Usage-based car insurance, akin to telematics, tracks driver behavior, but it also includes a feature that is particularly attractive to college students.

Usage-based car insurance offers discounts and lower premiums when you drive fewer miles annually. These “Pay-Per-Mile” plans are a smart option for affordable coverage if your car remains in the dorm lot or at home for most of the school year.

Temporary Car Insurance

While not every car insurance provider offers temporary policies, it’s an excellent option for college students who don’t plan on driving often.

Temporary auto insurance policies often provide six-month coverage and allow cancellation after the period ends. This is a practical choice for college students who won’t need coverage while at school or for those studying abroad for a semester.

Telematics Car Insurance For College Students

Finding creative ways to cut down on car insurance costs is key for college students. Telematics is one of the most effective tools for lowering your monthly premium.

Insurance companies use telematics to track and analyze your driving habits. The safer you drive, the lower your rates, and the higher the chances of getting discounts for safe driving.

How To Get Discounts

If you are looking to get discounts on your car insurance for college students in Pennsylvania, you can get it by:

  1. Comparing new policy options with available discounts from your other carriers
  2. Asking your current carrier about options to reduce your coverage costs

It is important to note that car insurance providers have different discounts many of which can be combined and some of which only apply to certain aspects of your coverage costs. Ask your current provider or investigate what other providers have for things like safe driver courses, being accident-free, keeping a low mileage vehicle, being active duty, or paying your policy annually instead of monthly.

How To Buy Car Insurance As A College Student In Pennsylvania

As a college student, the process for buying insurance in Pennsylvania is the same as anyone else.

  1. First, you’ll want to compare quotes from different providers based on the type of coverage you need. Tip: If you are a new driver or you are coming from out of state and unfamiliar with the terrain or weather in Pennsylvania, you might want to get additional coverage beyond the state minimums if you can afford it. This can protect you in the event of a collision.
  2. Second, you’ll want to decide which providers have the best discounts given your circumstances. You might, for example, be able to get a discount if you bundle things like renters insurance with your car insurance, and that discount could be more substantial than what a provider offers for things like safety features or good grades.
  3. Third, once you choose the policy you like best, purchase that policy and if you have a previous policy from a different provider, notify your former provider about that change. Note: This is more likely for people who are attending college out of state and need new coverage or for people who found a better deal online.

Once that is done, you will need to wait for the insurance card in order to make sure you comply with Pennsylvania car insurance laws.

Pennsylvania Car Insurance Laws To Know

Like many other states, Pennsylvania requires drivers to carry auto insurance. However, Pennsylvania has a specific mandate for Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage, which is not always required elsewhere.

A lapse in insurance coverage can result in suspension of your vehicle registration for 3 months. During such suspension, your registration plate, card, and driver’s license, where applicable, have to be surrendered to the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, after which you’ll have to pay a restoration fee and provide proof of insurance before your privileges are restored. Additional penalties can include a suspension of your driver’s license and a minimum $300 fine.

All vehicles registered in Pennsylvania, including trucks, cars, vans, recreational vehicles, and motorcycles, must maintain $15,000 for injury or death of one person, $30,000 for injury or death of more than one person, and $5,000 for damage to another person’s property.

Car insurance companies in Pennsylvania will provide you with an insurance identification card that is only valid for the period during which your coverage has been paid. This card must be carried with you so that you can present it to an officer if you are involved in an accident or traffic violation.

The minimum insurance coverage in Pennsylvania includes $10,000 for both PIP and PDL (Personal Damage Liability). While this amount may seem adequate, you might need more in the event of a serious accident. Experts often suggest buying more than the state-required minimum.

Our Methodology

To determine the lowest car insurance rates for Pennsylvania college students, we examined findings from various review sites, some of which analyzed rates from public filings via Quadrant Information Services. Our team's 25 years of combined insurance experience also played a key role in evaluating each carrier. Please remember that while the rates mentioned in this guide are correct, premiums can change daily and may differ based on the driver.

213

Quotes Analyzed

25

Years Of Industry Experience

22

Brands Reviewed

38+

Research Hours

FAQs

Who has the best car insurance for college students in Pennsylvania?

While GEICO generally has the lowest rates for college students, Progressive and State Farm are also worth considering depending on your driving record and coverage needs when looking for car insurance in Pennsylvania.

Do college students need car insurance in Pennsylvania?

Car insurance is required for everyone in Pennsylvania who drives. College students have the option to stay on their parents’ policy while living at home or to buy their own coverage after moving out.

Is car insurance more expensive for college students in Pennsylvania?

Car insurance is generally more costly for younger drivers in Pennsylvania. College students usually pay less than 16-year-olds but still face much higher rates compared to 25-year-old drivers.

How can you add a college student to a family policy?

If you plan to add a college student to your family insurance policy, speak with your insurance provider before they commence college. Typically, insurers will require the student’s new zip code and confirmation that their main address is still the family home. Extra requirements may be necessary for students studying out-of-state.

Can you stay on your parents’ car insurance if you move out?

If you keep your primary residence with your parents as a college student, you can stay on their car insurance. But once you move out and establish a new permanent address, you will need to secure your own auto insurance policy.

Sources

Go back to top