Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio 2024

For affordable and reliable car insurance for Ohio seniors, GEICO is a favored choice. With its competitive rates and full coverage options, it offers excellent value for their insurance needs.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Published:
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

This article will examine the best car insurance companies for seniors in Ohio and the average insurance costs in the state. Not selecting a good policy can cause higher costs and insufficient coverage. With over 15 years of experience in Ohio’s insurance market, I’ll provide insights to help you make a wise decision.

Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio, 2024

Best Car Insurance For Seniors, Ohio 2024

Compare The Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio

Overall Rating (Best 5.0) Best For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating (Best 1000) Average Auto Insurance Annual Rate Get A Quote
GEICO
4.9

Overall

A++

830

$680

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.8

Low-Mileage Drivers

A++

826

$863

Instant Quote
Allstate
4.7

Discounts

A+

816

$1,472

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For seniors in Ohio, GEICO is the best car insurance provider, offering competitive rates, numerous discounts, and user-friendly services. The average annual premium for seniors is around $680, making GEICO an affordable option. GEICO also provides discounts like the Defensive Driving discount for seniors who complete approved safety courses.

GEICO’s user-friendly app and website make managing policies, filing claims, and accessing roadside assistance easy and efficient, improving the customer experience. Their strong financial stability and high customer satisfaction ratings make GEICO a reliable choice for senior drivers. These factors ensure seniors get comprehensive coverage and excellent service at an affordable rate, positioning GEICO as the best car insurance choice in Ohio.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Affordable Rates: Competitive premiums.
  • Wide Discount Options: Numerous savings opportunities.
  • Easy Policy Management: User-friendly app.
Drawbacks
  • Limited Local Agents: Fewer face-to-face services.
  • Mixed Claim Experiences: Variable satisfaction with claims.
  • Coverage Limitations: Some options may be missing.

Best for Low-Mileage Drivers

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

State Farm is the top choice for low-mileage senior drivers in Ohio due to its tailored discounts and comprehensive coverage options. The Drive Safe & Save program offers significant savings based on mileage and safe driving habits, making it ideal for seniors who don’t drive often, allowing them to save considerably on premiums.

Additionally, State Farm’s top-notch customer service and high claim satisfaction rates guarantee that seniors receive prompt and reliable assistance when needed. The company’s financial stability ensures efficient claim handling, providing policyholders with peace of mind. Moreover, State Farm offers customizable coverage options to meet the unique needs of low-mileage drivers, ensuring they are adequately protected without paying for extras they don’t need.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Discounts for Good Driving: Rewards safe driving habits.
  • Customizable Insurance: Tailored to your needs.
  • Reliable Claims Satisfaction: High-quality customer service.
Drawbacks
  • More Expensive Premiums: Higher costs.
  • Limited Local Representation: Few in-person services.
  • No Gap Insurance Option: Some coverage gaps.

Best for Discounts

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Allstate is the top choice for car insurance for seniors in Ohio because of its extensive discount options. Seniors can enjoy savings like the Safe Driver discount for clean driving records and the Multi-Policy discount for bundling home and auto insurance. Additionally, Allstate provides a New Car discount and an Early Signing discount, making it easier for seniors to save on their premiums.

The Drivewise® program by Allstate tracks driving behaviors and offers discounts for safe driving, which is particularly beneficial for seniors who drive less often and more carefully. Allstate’s focus on personalized discount options ensures that seniors can maximize their savings based on their individual driving needs and patterns. This combination of numerous discounts, easy-to-use programs, and customer-focused policies makes Allstate the leading choice for seniors seeking the best car insurance discounts in Ohio.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Wide Discount Range: Many ways to save.
  • Drivewise Rewards: Benefits for safe drivers.
  • Tailored Coverage: Customizable policies.
Drawbacks
  • Premiums on the Higher Side: Not the least expensive.
  • Inconsistent Claims: Mixed satisfaction rates.
  • Few Local Agents: Limited in-person services.

Cheapest Overall Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio

Seniors on a fixed income need affordable car insurance. GEICO is the cheapest overall provider for seniors in Ohio , offering competitive rates and numerous discounts. With extensive coverage options at an average annual premium of $680, GEICO provides seniors with safe driver, multi-vehicle, and defensive driving discounts, making it the most affordable choice.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $680
2 Auto-Owners $870
3 State Farm $863
4 Progressive $1,074
5 Allstate $1,472

Cheapest Car Insurance For Seniors Over 65 In Ohio

Insurance rates for seniors over 65 can vary based on their driving habits and health condition. GEICO offers the most competitive rates for this demographic, with an average annual premium of $694. GEICO’s discounts and usage-based programs are beneficial for older drivers who drive less frequently, keeping their insurance costs low.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $694
2 Auto-Owners $889
3 State Farm $875
4 Progressive $1,102
5 Allstate $1,465

Cheapest Car Insurance For Seniors Over 70 In Ohio

With age, insurance premiums can rise due to perceived higher risk. However, GEICO offers the lowest rates for seniors over 70, averaging $720 annually. GEICO’s policies are crafted to suit senior drivers, providing affordable and comprehensive coverage.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $720
2 Auto-Owners $970
3 State Farm $905
4 Progressive $1,235
5 Allstate $1,570

Cheapest Car Insurance In Ohio For Seniors Over 75

For those over 75, GEICO is a top contender, offering an average annual premium of $770. The discounts for safe and defensive driving make GEICO a budget-friendly option for older drivers.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $770
2 Auto-Owners $1,089
3 State Farm $975
4 Progressive $1,526
5 Allstate $1,722

Most Affordable Car Insurance For Seniors Over 85 In Ohio

Seniors over 85 usually face higher insurance premiums due to increased health risks and accident potential. Still, GEICO provides competitive rates, averaging $800 per year, with the help of various senior discounts.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $800
2 Auto-Owners $1,215
3 State Farm $1,126
4 Progressive $1,401
5 Allstate $1,814

Cheapest Car Insurance In Ohio For Seniors With A Ticket

Getting a driving ticket can significantly raise insurance rates. State Farm offers the most affordable rates for seniors with a ticket, with an average annual premium of $1,140. State Farm’s forgiving policies and post-ticket clean record discounts make it a great option.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,140
2 GEICO $1,601
3 Progressive $1,880
4 Travelers $1,816
5 Nationwide $1,062

Cheapest Car Insurance For Seniors With A DUI In Ohio

Having a DUI on your record can cause insurance premiums to soar. State Farm offers the most affordable rates for seniors with a DUI, averaging $1,160 per year. State Farm’s specialized programs help mitigate the cost impacts of a DUI.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,160
2 GEICO $2,126
3 Progressive $1,720
4 Auto-Owners $2,211
5 Nationwide $1,620

Cheapest Car Insurance for Good Senior Drivers

Good drivers often benefit from reduced insurance premiums. GEICO provides the cheapest rates for seniors with clean driving records, averaging $680 annually, supported by extensive good driver discounts.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $680
2 Auto-Owners $870
3 State Farm $863
4 Progressive $1,074
5 Allstate $1,472

Cheapest Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio After An Accident

Post-accident insurance premiums can be expensive. State Farm provides the best rates for seniors, averaging $1,240 annually. Their accident forgiveness programs effectively manage the costs.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,240
2 GEICO $1,674
3 Progressive $2,340
4 Auto-Owners $1,590
5 Nationwide $1,316

How Much Is Car Insurance For Seniors In Ohio?

Car insurance premiums for seniors in Ohio can fluctuate significantly based on factors like age, driving history, vehicle type, and coverage level. Seniors generally face higher rates due to age-related risks such as slower reflexes and health concerns. Nonetheless, many insurers offer discounts and programs to help manage these costs.

Seniors in Ohio can expect an average annual cost of $1,000 to $2,500 for full coverage. This average includes different discounts and coverage options. The table below displays the average yearly costs of five popular providers for seniors in Ohio.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $680
2 Auto-Owners $870
3 State Farm $863
4 Progressive $1,074
5 Allstate $1,472

Factors Influencing Auto Insurance Rates

Various factors that affect car insurance rates for seniors include:

    1. Age: Insurance rates generally increase with age, particularly after 70, due to heightened risk.
    2. Driving Record: Keeping a clean driving record can lead to lower rates.
    3. Mileage: Seniors who drive fewer miles may see reduced premiums with usage-based insurance options.
    4. Coverage Level: The cost of insurance can be influenced by the chosen mix of liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.
    5. Discounts: Seniors may qualify for discounts such as safe driver, defensive driving course, and multi-policy discounts.

By being aware of these factors and shopping around, seniors in Ohio can obtain car insurance that is both affordable and meets their specific needs.

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates for Senior Drivers – by US State

Securing affordable car insurance is critical for senior drivers due to their particular challenges on the road. This section gives a comprehensive overview of the lowest rates available for seniors in each state and the insurance companies offering them. By comparing these options, senior drivers can make informed choices that balance affordability with sufficient coverage.

State Average Annual Premium
Alabama $1,750
Alaska $1,890
Arizona $1,920
Arkansas $1,860
California $1,919
Colorado $2,150
Connecticut $2,020
Delaware $2,100
Florida $2,300
Georgia $1,980
Hawaii $1,700
Idaho $1,760
Illinois $1,870
Indiana $1,800
Iowa $1,720
Kansas $1,840
Kentucky $2,010
Louisiana $2,450
Maine $1,690
Maryland $2,080
Massachusetts $2,000
Michigan $2,500
Minnesota $1,950
Mississippi $1,830
Missouri $1,810
Montana $1,880
Nebraska $1,910
Nevada $2,200
New Hampshire $1,740
New Jersey $2,220
New Mexico $1,900
New York $2,300
North Carolina $1,760
North Dakota $1,890
Ohio $1,720
Oklahoma $1,870
Oregon $1,980
Pennsylvania $2,100
Rhode Island $2,230
South Carolina $2,050
South Dakota $1,930
Tennessee $1,750
Texas $2,100
Utah $1,880
Vermont $1,710
Virginia $1,790
Washington $1,950
West Virginia $1,930
Wisconsin $1,780
Wyoming $1,850

Why Do Car Insurance Rates Increase For Seniors?

The increase in car insurance rates for seniors is often due to several age-related factors and associated risks. Key reasons include:

Increased Accident Risk

Statistics show that older drivers are more susceptible to accidents compared to middle-aged drivers. This is often due to age-related factors like decreased reflexes, vision problems, and hearing loss, which can impair their ability to respond quickly to road hazards.

Health Issues

With advancing age, individuals are more likely to have chronic health conditions or take medications that could hinder their driving. Conditions like arthritis, dementia, and heart disease can affect driving performance, and medications causing drowsiness or dizziness can further raise accident risk.

Higher Injury Severity

Seniors often experience more serious injuries in accidents because of fragile bones and slower healing rates. These increased medical costs are factored into the premium calculations by insurance providers.

Frequency of Claims

The greater risk of accidents and severe injuries for seniors often results in more frequent insurance claims compared to younger drivers. This frequent claiming raises the costs for insurance companies, which leads to higher premiums for seniors.

Experience and Mileage

Seniors, who often have decades of driving experience, generally drive fewer miles as they get older. While this can result in some discounts, insurance premiums may still rise because reduced driving does not completely offset the age-related risks.

How Can Seniors Save On Car Insurance?

There are several ways seniors can reduce their car insurance costs. Here are some effective techniques for saving on premiums:

1. Take Advantage of Discounts

Insurance companies often provide discounts for senior drivers, including:

  • Defensive Driving Course Discount: Seniors who complete an approved defensive driving course can receive significant discounts, refreshing driving skills and updating traffic law knowledge.
  • Low Mileage Discount: Seniors who drive less can qualify for low mileage discounts. Usage-based insurance programs track mileage and offer savings for reduced driving.
  • Safe Driver Discount: A clean driving record without accidents or violations can earn seniors a safe driver discount.
  • Multi-Policy Discount: Bundling car insurance with other types of insurance, such as home or renters insurance, can result in multi-policy discounts.

2. Review and Adjust Coverage

Seniors should periodically reassess their insurance coverage:

  • Raise Deductibles: Opting for higher deductibles can lower premiums, but ensure the deductible is affordable in case you need to make a claim.
  • Reduce Coverage on Older Cars: For older vehicles, dropping collision and comprehensive coverage can be a smart move if the car’s value is minimal.
  • Consider Usage-Based Insurance: Programs like State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save or Allstate’s Drivewise offer discounts based on actual driving habits, benefiting seniors who drive safely and less often.

3. Shop Around

Using Insuranceopedia to compare quotes from different insurance providers can assist seniors in finding the best rates. With each company calculating premiums differently, shopping around can uncover considerable savings.

4. Maintain a Good Credit Score

In several states, insurance providers factor in credit scores when determining premiums. Maintaining a good credit score can help you secure lower rates.

5. Install Safety Devices

Vehicles with safety features like anti-theft devices, airbags, and anti-lock brakes can get more discounts. These features help reduce the risk of accidents and theft, lowering the cost of insurance.

6. Consider Group Insurance

Membership in groups like AARP can offer lower rates on group insurance plans. These plans often provide additional perks and discounts for members.

7. Ask About Senior Discounts

Certain insurers offer age-related discounts specifically for senior drivers. Make sure to ask your insurance company if they provide any discounts based on age.

8. Regularly Review Insurance Needs

Seniors’ changing driving habits lead to different insurance needs. Regularly reviewing and adjusting coverage can avoid paying for unnecessary insurance. By employing these strategies, seniors can manage and lower their car insurance expenses, ensuring they get the best value for their coverage.

Car Insurance Discounts For Seniors

Seniors can access various discounts from car insurance companies. Keep an eye out for these popular ones:

1. Defensive Driving Course Discount

Insurance companies often offer discounts to seniors who finish an authorized defensive driving course. These courses refresh driving techniques and update traffic law knowledge.

2. Low Mileage Discount

Retired seniors who drive fewer miles can qualify for low mileage discounts, making it particularly advantageous for those who no longer commute regularly.

3. Safe Driver Discount

Seniors with no accidents or traffic violations on their driving record can benefit from a safe driver discount. This discount is commonly awarded for careful and responsible driving.

4. Multi-Policy Discount

By bundling car insurance with other coverages like home or renters insurance, seniors can access a multi-policy discount. Bundling policies with the same company often results in meaningful savings.

5. Good Student Discount

While this doesn’t apply directly to seniors, including good student grandchildren on their policy could lead to a discount. Maintaining a certain GPA is usually required.

6. Vehicle Safety Discount

Installing safety features, including anti-lock brakes, airbags, and anti-theft systems, can result in an insurance discount. These features help mitigate the risk of accidents and theft, leading to lower insurance costs.

7. Usage-Based Insurance Discount

Drive Safe & Save from State Farm and Drivewise from Allstate monitor your driving habits and offer discounts for safe driving. Seniors who drive infrequently and safely can benefit from lower insurance premiums.

8. Affinity Group Discount

By joining organizations like AARP, seniors can access group insurance plans that feature additional discounts. These group plans frequently provide lower rates for members.

9. Homeowner Discount

Seniors who have home ownership may qualify for a homeowner discount. This discount, available from many insurers, can significantly cut down on overall premium expenses.

10. Loyalty Discount

Customers who stay with their insurer for an extended period often benefit from loyalty discounts. This long-term commitment can result in decreased insurance premiums.

Our methodology

Evaluating car insurance for seniors in Ohio involves a detailed process that examines several key factors. We compare average annual and monthly premiums by different age groups and driving records. The availability of discounts for defensive driving courses, low mileage, and bundling policies is assessed. We review customer satisfaction scores from J.D. Power and Consumer Reports to measure overall experience. Financial stability is checked using ratings from A.M. Best and Standard & Poor's. Additionally, we explore the range of coverage options and specialized programs for seniors, including usage-based insurance. We review the efficiency of claim handling and support services by looking at settlement times and customer service quality. Expert opinions and user feedback are integrated into our evaluation. Data from J.D. Power, A.M. Best, Consumer Reports, insurer publications, and customer reviews on Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau help us provide well-rounded recommendations for senior drivers in Ohio.

143

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

39

Brands Reviewed

35+

Research Hours

Who offers the lowest car insurance premiums for seniors?

GEICO frequently offers the most affordable premiums for seniors, averaging around $680 annually. They provide competitive rates and a variety of discounts aimed at older drivers.

Does retiring affect car insurance rates?

Yes, retiring can affect car insurance rates, potentially lowering them if you drive less. Many insurance companies provide discounts for low mileage, which can help reduce costs for retirees.

Do older drivers face higher car insurance rates after 65?

Yes, car insurance rates often become higher for drivers after age 65. This increase is due to slower reflexes, a higher accident risk, and increased medical costs related to injuries, which affect insurance premiums.

Go back to top