Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania 2024

In Pennsylvania, seniors frequently choose GEICO for car insurance because of its low prices and wide range of coverage options, guaranteeing great service and value.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Published:
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

This article will compare the leading car insurance options for Pennsylvania seniors and talk about the average insurance costs in the Golden State. Not picking a good policy can result in higher costs and less coverage.

Drawing from over 15 years of experience in the Pennsylvania insurance industry, I’ll offer insights to help you make a smart decision.

Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania, 2024

Best Car Insurance For Seniors, Pennsylvania, 2024

Compare The Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania

Overall Rating (Best 5.0) Best For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating (Best 1000) Average Auto Insurance Annual Rate Get A Quote
GEICO
4.9

Overall

A++

830

$1,310

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.8

Low-Mileage Drivers

A++

826

$1,105

Instant Quote
Allstate
4.7

Discounts

A+

816

$1,119

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

The best car insurance for seniors in Pennsylvania is GEICO, known for its affordable pricing, numerous discounts, and convenient services. With an average annual premium of $1,310, GEICO helps reduce the financial load for older drivers. Additionally, seniors can benefit from discounts like the Defensive Driving discount for completing safety courses.

The user-friendly mobile app and website from GEICO make policy management, claims filing, and roadside assistance easy and efficient, enhancing the customer experience. With strong financial stability and high customer satisfaction ratings, GEICO is a reliable choice for senior drivers. These factors ensure comprehensive coverage and excellent service at an affordable rate, making GEICO the best overall car insurance choice in Pennsylvania.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Low Premiums: Competitive pricing.
  • Lots of Discounts: Many ways to save.
  • Easy App: User-friendly for managing policies.
Drawbacks
  • Limited In-Person Services: Fewer local agents.
  • Mixed Claim Reviews: Variable satisfaction with claims.
  • Coverage Shortfalls: Some coverage options may be lacking.

Best for Low-Mileage Drivers

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

State Farm is the leading car insurance company for low-mileage seniors in Pennsylvania, thanks to its customized discounts and extensive coverage options. Seniors who drive infrequently can benefit from the Drive Safe & Save program, which provides significant discounts based on mileage and safe driving, resulting in considerable savings on their premiums.

State Farm’s robust customer service and high claim satisfaction rates ensure that seniors receive timely and reliable assistance when necessary. The company’s strong financial stability guarantees efficient claim handling, offering peace of mind to policyholders. Additionally, State Farm provides a range of customizable coverage options tailored to the needs of low-mileage drivers, ensuring they are adequately protected without paying for unneeded extras.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Discounts for Safe Driving: Rewards for good driving habits.
  • Custom Coverage Options: Tailored to meet individual needs.
  • High Claim Service Ratings: Reliable customer support.
Drawbacks
  • Premiums on the Higher Side: Not the lowest cost.
  • Limited In-Person Services: Fewer local agents.
  • Lacks Gap Insurance: Missing certain coverage options.

Best for Discounts

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer satisfaction/reviews
8/10 Claims/ Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Allstate is the leading car insurance provider for seniors in Pennsylvania when it comes to discounts. Seniors can take advantage of many savings opportunities, like the Safe Driver discount for clean driving records and the Multi-Policy discount for bundling home and auto insurance. Allstate also offers a New Car discount and an Early Signing discount, further lowering premiums for seniors.

The innovative Drivewise® program from Allstate tracks driving habits and gives discounts for safe driving, making it perfect for seniors who drive less frequently and more cautiously. Allstate’s commitment to personalized discount options helps seniors optimize their savings according to their specific needs and driving patterns. This combination of wide-ranging discounts, user-friendly programs, and customer-focused policies makes Allstate the top choice for seniors looking for the best car insurance discounts in Pennsylvania.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Abundant Discounts: Many savings options.
  • Drivewise Benefits: Rewards for safe driving.
  • Flexible Policies: Customizable coverage.
Drawbacks
  • Higher Premium Costs: Not the cheapest option.
  • Variable Claim Experiences: Mixed feedback.
  • Limited Local Presence: Fewer in-person services.

Cheapest Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania

For seniors on a fixed income, affordable car insurance is a must. GEICO is the cheapest provider for seniors in Pennsylvania, with competitive rates and a wide range of discounts.

Offering extensive coverage options at an average annual premium of $1,310, GEICO provides seniors with discounts like safe driver, multi-vehicle, and defensive driving, making it the best choice for affordability.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $1,310
2 Auto-Owners $1,467
3 State Farm $1,498
4 Progressive $2,179
5 Kemper Insurance $1,480

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors Over 65 In Pennsylvania

Insurance rates for those over 65 can differ based on driving patterns and health status. State Farm offers the most affordable rates for this age group, with an average annual premium of $1,090.

State Farm’s discounts and usage-based programs are well-suited for older drivers who drive less often, keeping their expenses low.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,090
2 Auto-Owners $1,167
3 GEICO $1,298
4 Progressive $1,525
5 Allstate $1,126

Cheapest Car Insurance In Pennsylvania For Seniors Over 70

Insurance rates tend to increase with age due to perceived higher risk, but Allstate offers the best rates for seniors over 70, with an average annual premium of $1,208. Allstate tailors its policies to senior drivers, ensuring they receive affordable and comprehensive coverage.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 Allstate $1,208
2 GEICO $1,314
3 State Farm $1,137
4 Progressive $1,704
5 Auto-Owners $1,240

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors Over 75 In Pennsylvania

For seniors over 75, State Farm stands out as a top option, providing an average annual premium of $1,236. Its safe driving and defensive driving discounts make State Farm an affordable choice for older drivers.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,236
2 Allstate $1,420
3 GEICO $1,427
4 Progressive $1,998
5 Auto-Owners $1,362

Most Affordable Car Insurance For Seniors Over 85 In Pennsylvania

Seniors over 85 typically see higher insurance rates because of increased health risks and the potential for accidents. Yet, GEICO provides competitive pricing, with an average annual premium of $1,970, aided by various senior discounts.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $1,970
2 Mercury Insurance $2,109
3 State Farm $2,276
4 Progressive $2,437
5 Allstate $2,420

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors with a Ticket In Pennsylvania

Insurance rates can spike significantly after receiving a driving ticket. Nationwide offers the lowest rates for seniors with a ticket, averaging $1,229 annually. Nationwide’s forgiving policies and discounts for keeping a clean record post-ticket make it an excellent option.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 Nationwide $1,229
2 GEICO $1,770
3 Progressive $1,778
4 Allstate $1,263
5 State Farm $1,369

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors with a DUI

Insurance premiums skyrocket with a DUI on record. State Farm provides the most affordable rates for seniors with a DUI, averaging $1,368 annually. State Farm’s specialized programs help ease the financial burden of a DUI.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 State Farm $1,368
2 GEICO $2,905
3 Auto-Owners $3,590
4 Allstate $2,190
5 Nationwide $1,370

Cheapest Senior Car Insurance For Good Drivers In Pennsylvania

Seniors with excellent driving histories generally receive lower insurance rates. GEICO provides the most affordable premiums, averaging $1,310 annually, thanks to its extensive good driver discounts.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $1,310
2 Auto-Owners $1,467
3 State Farm $1,498
4 Progressive $2,179
5 Kemper Insurance $1,480

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors After an Accident

Insurance rates often rise significantly after an accident. Nationwide provides the best rates for seniors, averaging $1,207 per year. Their accident forgiveness programs help manage the increased costs.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 Nationwide $1,207
2 GEICO $2,009
3 Progressive $2,498
4 Allstate $1,520
5 State Farm $1,409

How Much Is Car Insurance For Seniors In Pennsylvania?

Car insurance rates for seniors in Pennsylvania can vary based on factors like age, driving history, vehicle type, and coverage level. Seniors tend to pay higher premiums due to age-related risks such as slower reflexes and potential health problems. However, many insurance companies offer discounts and programs to help mitigate these costs.

In Pennsylvania, seniors can expect to pay approximately $1,000 to $2,000 per year for full coverage on average. This average accounts for various discounts and levels of coverage. Below is a table showing the average annual costs for five major providers for seniors in Pennsylvania.

Rank Insurance Company Average Annual Premium
1 GEICO $1,310
2 Auto-Owners $1,467
3 State Farm $1,498
4 Progressive $2,179
5 Kemper Insurance $1,480

Factors Influencing Car Insurance Rates

Several factors impact car insurance rates for seniors:

  1. Age: Insurance costs usually rise with age, especially after 70, due to increased risk.
  2. Driving Record: Having a clean driving record can significantly lower insurance rates.
  3. Mileage: Seniors who drive fewer miles might benefit from lower premiums through usage-based programs.
  4. Coverage Level: The combination of liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage affects the overall insurance cost.
  5. Discounts: Seniors may qualify for various discounts, such as safe driver, defensive driving, and multi-policy discounts.

By evaluating these factors and seeking out the best rates, seniors in Pennsylvania can find car insurance that is both economical and tailored to their needs.

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates For Senior Drivers – By US State

It’s essential for senior drivers to find the most affordable car insurance due to their unique challenges on the road. This section reviews the lowest car insurance rates available for seniors in every state and highlights the insurers providing these competitive rates. By comparing these options, seniors can make informed choices that ensure both cost savings and proper coverage.

State Average Annual Premium
Alabama $1,750
Alaska $1,890
Arizona $1,920
Arkansas $1,860
California $1,919
Colorado $2,150
Connecticut $2,020
Delaware $2,100
Florida $2,331
Georgia $1,450
Hawaii $1,700
Idaho $1,760
Illinois $1,870
Indiana $1,800
Iowa $1,720
Kansas $1,840
Kentucky $2,010
Louisiana $2,450
Maine $1,690
Maryland $2,080
Massachusetts $2,000
Michigan $2,500
Minnesota $1,950
Mississippi $1,830
Missouri $1,810
Montana $1,880
Nebraska $1,910
Nevada $2,200
New Hampshire $1,740
New Jersey $2,220
New Mexico $1,900
New York $2,300
North Carolina $1,760
North Dakota $1,890
Ohio $1,720
Oklahoma $1,870
Oregon $1,980
Pennsylvania $2,100
Rhode Island $2,230
South Carolina $2,050
South Dakota $1,930
Tennessee $1,750
Texas $2,100
Utah $1,880
Vermont $1,710
Virginia $1,790
Washington $1,950
West Virginia $1,930
Wisconsin $1,780
Wyoming $1,850

Why Do Car Insurance Rates Increase For Seniors?

Several age-related factors contribute to higher car insurance rates for seniors. The main reasons include:

Increased Accident Risk

Senior drivers statistically face a higher risk of accidents compared to middle-aged drivers. This is largely due to age-related changes, including slower reflexes, diminished eyesight, and hearing loss, which can hinder their ability to react swiftly to road hazards.

Health Issues

Chronic health conditions and medications affecting driving abilities become more common with age. Conditions like arthritis, dementia, and heart disease can impact driving skills, and medications causing drowsiness or dizziness can further elevate the risk of accidents.

Higher Injury Severity

Due to more brittle bones and slower recovery times, seniors are more likely to suffer severe injuries in accidents. This higher risk results in greater medical expenses, which insurance companies consider when calculating insurance premiums.

Frequency of Claims

Due to a higher likelihood of accidents and severe injuries, seniors may submit more claims than younger drivers. This higher claim frequency translates to increased costs for insurers, leading to higher insurance premiums for seniors.

Experience and Mileage

Seniors often cut back on their driving as they age, despite having extensive driving experience. Although this can lead to some savings, insurance companies may still raise rates because decreased mileage doesn’t fully offset the risks associated with age.

How Can Seniors Save On Car Insurance?

Seniors can take advantage of several strategies to lower their car insurance premiums. Here are some proven ways to save:

1. Take Advantage of Discounts

Discounts specifically for senior drivers are offered by many insurance companies. These can include:

  • Defensive Driving Course Discount: Completing an approved defensive driving course can lead to significant discounts, refreshing driving skills and updating traffic law knowledge.
  • Low Mileage Discount: Seniors who drive less can qualify for low mileage discounts. Usage-based insurance programs track mileage and offer savings for reduced driving.
  • Safe Driver Discount: A clean driving record without accidents or violations can earn seniors a safe driver discount.
  • Multi-Policy Discount: Bundling car insurance with other types of insurance, such as home or renters insurance, can result in multi-policy discounts.

2. Review and Adjust Coverage

Regularly reviewing and adjusting coverage is crucial for seniors:

  • Raise Deductibles: Higher deductibles can lead to lower premiums, but ensure the deductible is affordable in case a claim is filed.
  • Reduce Coverage on Older Cars: Dropping collision and comprehensive coverage for older vehicles can save money if the car’s value is low.
  • Consider Usage-Based Insurance: Programs like State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save or Allstate’s Drivewise reward safe driving habits with discounts. Seniors who drive less can benefit from lower premiums.

3. Shop Around

Seniors can discover the best rates by using Insuranceopedia to compare quotes from various insurance providers. Since each company uses different methods to calculate premiums, shopping around can result in significant savings.

4. Maintain a Good Credit Score

Insurance companies in some states use credit scores to determine premiums. A good credit score can result in lower insurance rates.

5. Install Safety Devices

By equipping your vehicle with safety features like anti-theft devices, airbags, and anti-lock brakes, you can receive additional discounts. These features decrease the chances of accidents and theft, resulting in lower insurance premiums.

6. Consider Group Insurance

Affiliation with groups like AARP can give you access to group insurance plans with lower rates. These plans frequently offer additional advantages and discounts for members.

7. Ask About Senior Discounts

Some insurance providers give special discounts to senior drivers. It’s worth asking your insurer if they have any age-related discounts available.

8. Regularly Review Insurance Needs

As seniors’ driving patterns change, so do their insurance requirements. Regularly reviewing and modifying coverage can help prevent paying for excess coverage. By adopting these strategies, seniors can efficiently manage and lower their car insurance expenses, ensuring the best value for their coverage.

Car Insurance Discounts For Seniors

Seniors may benefit from several discounts available through car insurance companies. Here are some common options to consider:

1. Defensive Driving Course Discount

Several insurance companies give discounts to seniors who take an approved defensive driving course. These courses refresh driving skills and offer the latest information on traffic laws.

2. Low Mileage Discount

Low mileage discounts are available for seniors who drive less frequently, which is especially useful for those who have retired and stopped commuting daily.

3. Safe Driver Discount

Seniors who keep a clean driving history, free from accidents and violations, may be eligible for a safe driver discount. This discount is typically given for careful driving.

4. Multi-Policy Discount

Combining car insurance with home or renters insurance allows seniors to qualify for a multi-policy discount. This bundling typically results in notable savings with the same insurer.

5. Good Student Discount

Although not directly related to seniors, having good student grandchildren on their policy could make them eligible for a discount. This generally requires the students to maintain a specific GPA.

6. Vehicle Safety Discount

Equipping your vehicle with safety enhancements such as anti-lock brakes, airbags, and anti-theft devices can lead to a discount. These features decrease the risk of accidents and theft, reducing insurance costs.

7. Usage-Based Insurance Discount

Programs such as Drive Safe & Save by State Farm and Drivewise by Allstate assess driving habits to offer discounts based on safe driving. Seniors who drive less and maintain good driving practices can lower their premiums.

8. Affinity Group Discount

Organizations such as AARP often provide group insurance plans that come with added discounts. These plans usually offer lower rates for members.

9. Homeowner Discount

If seniors own their homes, they may be able to obtain a homeowner discount. This discount, offered by many insurance companies, can lead to lower premium costs.

10. Loyalty Discount

Staying with the same insurer for a number of years can earn you a loyalty discount. Insurance companies often reward long-term customers with reduced premiums.

Our methodology

Our approach to evaluating car insurance providers for seniors in Pennsylvania involves a detailed analysis of multiple factors. We compare annual and monthly premiums based on age and driving history. We assess discounts offered for defensive driving courses, low mileage, and policy bundling. Customer satisfaction metrics from sources like J.D. Power and Consumer Reports are analyzed to understand the customer experience. Financial stability is assessed through ratings from agencies such as A.M. Best and Standard & Poor's. Additionally, we examine the variety of coverage options and senior-specific programs, including usage-based insurance plans. In addition to reviewing insurance rates and coverage options, we evaluate claim handling and customer support efficiency, including settlement times and service quality. Expert assessments and user feedback enhance our analysis. We utilize data from J.D. Power, A.M. Best, Consumer Reports, insurance company publications, and customer reviews from platforms like Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau. This comprehensive approach ensures our recommendations are relevant and effective for senior drivers in Pennsylvania.

147

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

42

Brands Reviewed

35+

Research Hours

What car insurance company offers the most affordable rates for seniors?

GEICO is known for offering the cheapest rates for seniors, with an average annual premium of around $1,310. Their competitive rates and range of discounts are well-suited for older drivers.

Do insurance rates go down when you stop working?

Car insurance rates might decrease when you retire if you drive fewer miles. Many insurance providers offer discounts for lower mileage, which can help reduce premiums for retired individuals.

Do insurance costs increase for those over 65?

Insurance costs often increase for drivers over 65. This is due to age-related factors such as diminished reflexes, greater risk of accidents, and higher medical expenses from injuries, which lead insurers to raise premiums.

Go back to top