Best Car Insurance For Teens In Ohio

In Ohio, State Farm stands out as the best car insurance option for teenagers, in my professional opinion.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Published:
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

State Farm tops our list, but there are several other Ohio car insurance companies that offer great options for teens. USAA is best for military personnel, Allstate suits low-mileage drivers, State Farm is the most affordable, and GEICO excels in roadside service.

This article will evaluate the top-rated insurance companies for teens in Ohio, helping you find affordable and reliable coverage. Without the right insurance, teens may face steep premiums and inadequate protection. With over 15 years of experience in insurance, I know the importance of making the right decision for your young driver.

Best Car Insurance For Teens In Ohio, 2024

Best Car Insurance For Teens, Ohio, 2024

Compare Car Insurance For Teens In Ohio 2024

Overall Rating Best For A.M Best Rating J.D Power Rating Average Annual Rate (Liability Only) Get A Quote
State Farm
4.9

Best Overall

A++

838

$7,740

Instant Quote
USAA
4.9

Military Members

A++

860

$1,321

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Most Affordable

A++

838

$3,840

Instant Quote
Allstate
4.7

Low-Mileage Drivers

A-

809

$1,780

Instant Quote
GEICO
4.8

Roadside Assistance

A++

801

$1,544

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Car Insurance For Teens In Ohio


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

State Farm is the top insurance company for teen drivers in Ohio, offering a blend of affordability, coverage options, and customer service. The company provides competitive rates specifically designed for young drivers, which are often more affordable than those offered by other major insurers in the state. This is important for families who need to balance cost with comprehensive coverage.

State Farm also offers various discounts that help keep premiums low for teens. Their Steer Clear® program, aimed at young drivers, rewards safe driving with discounts. Additionally, bundling auto insurance with other policies, like homeowners or renters insurance, can lead to significant savings.

Besides its pricing benefits, State Farm is known for its outstanding customer service and a broad network of local agents across Ohio. This ensures families have access to personalized support, making the insurance process easier for new drivers and their parents.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Favorable rates for teen drivers
  • Safe driving discounts available
  • Local agent network is vast
Drawbacks
  • Costs escalate without discounts
  • Absent accident forgiveness program
  • Limited online tools and support

Best for Military Families

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

USAA is the best choice for military families with teen drivers in Ohio, offering outstanding customer service, tailored coverage, and affordability. As an insurer dedicated exclusively to military members and their families, USAA understands the unique challenges of frequent relocations and deployments. This expertise translates into flexible policies that provide peace of mind.

USAA frequently offers some of the most competitive rates for teen drivers, often beating out other major insurers. Their SafePilot® program also offers discounts for safe driving, which is beneficial for young, less experienced drivers. Additionally, USAA provides accident forgiveness for qualified policyholders, helping to reduce the financial impact of a first accident.

Moreover, USAA’s commitment to customer service is unmatched, with high satisfaction ratings and a reputation for quickly resolving claims. For military families in Ohio, USAA offers reliable, affordable, and tailored coverage that meets their specific needs.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Cost-effective rates for military members
  • Rewards for safe driving behavior
  • Excellent customer care
Drawbacks
  • Only for military families
  • Few local agents in the network
  • Gap insurance option unavailable

Best for Low-Mileage Drivers

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Allstate ranks as the best insurance company for low-mileage teen drivers in Ohio because of its tailored discounts and usage-based insurance programs. Allstate’s Milewise® program is a perfect choice for teens who drive less frequently, allowing them to pay based on the miles they actually drive. This pay-per-mile feature can yield significant savings, making it a budget-friendly choice for teens who primarily drive to school or for occasional outings.

Additionally, Allstate offers various discounts that are advantageous to teen drivers, such as good student discounts and rewards for safe driving through the Allstate Drivewise® program. These discounts can further decrease the overall cost of premiums, making it more affordable for families to obtain quality coverage.

Moreover, Allstate’s wide network of agents across Ohio provides personalized service, guiding parents and teens through the complexities of car insurance with ease. For low-mileage teen drivers in Ohio, Allstate delivers both affordability and flexibility.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Special rates for drivers with low mileage
  • Available discount for good students
  • Extensive agent coverage
Drawbacks
  • Higher premiums in the absence of discounts
  • Limited availability for pay-per-mile insurance
  • Additional cost for accident forgiveness protection

Most Affordable

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

State Farm is the most budget-friendly insurance provider for teen drivers in Ohio, thanks to its competitive pricing and a variety of discount options. Unlike many other insurers, State Farm is committed to offering affordable rates for young drivers, helping families manage the typically high costs associated with insuring teens. A key factor in keeping their rates low is the range of discounts available specifically for young drivers, such as good student discounts and incentives for safe driving through the Steer Clear® program.

Additionally, State Farm’s broad presence in Ohio allows for personalized service, helping families secure the most cost-effective coverage tailored to their needs. Bundling discounts with other policies like home or renters insurance can further reduce overall insurance expenses. For families seeking both affordability and comprehensive coverage, State Farm consistently provides some of the best-value options for teen drivers in Ohio.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Secure financial standing
  • Straightforward claims process
  • Broad selection of coverage options
Drawbacks
  • Limited options for accident forgiveness
  • Elevated premiums for minor violations
  • No coverage for new vehicle replacement

Best for Roadside Assistance

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

In Ohio, GEICO offers outstanding roadside assistance for teen drivers with its extensive and cost-effective service. Their assistance covers a range of emergencies including flat tires, dead batteries, and lockouts—problems that new drivers often face. This support is crucial for teens who are still learning the ropes of driving.

GEICO’s roadside assistance is available 24/7 through a mobile app that is user-friendly, making it easy for young drivers to get the help they need. It is offered at an affordable price, either as an add-on to an auto insurance policy or through a membership. Additionally, GEICO’s strong customer service ensures that teens receive prompt and reliable support.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Affordable premiums for teens
  • Extensive discount opportunities
  • Mobile app is user-friendly
Drawbacks
  • Local agent support is limited
  • Increased rates after accidents
  • Basic coverage options only

Average Teenage Car Insurance Rates In Ohio – By City

City Average Monthly Premium Average Annual Premium
Columbus $345 $4,140
Cleveland $370 $4,440
Cincinnati $345 $4,140
Toledo $364 $4,380
Akron $337 $4,050
Dayton $355 $4,260
Parma $378 $4,536
Canton $360 $4,320
Youngstown $352 $4,224
Lorain $365 $4,390
Hamilton $347 $4,164

How To Get Cheap Car Insurance For Teens In Ohio

It’s not always easy to find affordable car insurance for teen drivers in Ohio, but these strategies can help you find a policy that provides both comprehensive coverage and a reasonable price:

Assess Driving Habits

Review how frequently and how far your teen drives. Low-mileage drivers can benefit from usage-based insurance plans such as Allstate’s Milewise® or GEICO’s DriveEasy.

1

Shop Around for Quotes

Compare quotes from different auto insurers, such as State Farm and USAA, which often provide good rates for teenage drivers in Ohio.

2

Ask About Discounts

Inquire about teen driver discounts, including those for good grades, participating in safe driving programs, and having multiple insurance policies.

3

Consider Usage-Based Insurance

If your teen’s driving is infrequent, pay-per-mile or usage-based insurance options could be a cost-effective choice.

4

Choose a Higher Deductible

Raise your deductible to lower your premium, but make sure you have the funds to pay it if needed.

5

Bundle Policies

Bundle your teen’s car insurance with additional policies, such as homeowners or renters insurance, to qualify for discount rates.

6

Add to an Existing Policy

It’s often cheaper to add your teen to your existing policy than to purchase a separate insurance policy.

7

Enroll in a Safe Driving Course

Encourage your teen to sign up for a defensive driving course to improve their driving abilities and potentially lower their insurance costs.

8

Review and Update Regularly

As your teen becomes more experienced behind the wheel, periodically review their policy to check for new discounts.

9

Why Is Car Insurance So Expensive For Teens?

Car insurance is more expensive for teens primarily due to their inexperience and a higher accident risk. Statistically, teens are more frequently involved in accidents than older drivers, which leads insurance companies to raise premiums to compensate for the elevated risk.

Key Reasons For High Costs

  1. Lack of Experience: Due to limited time on the road, teens are more likely to make driving errors that could lead to accidents.
  2. Higher Accident Rates: Studies show that teens, particularly males, are more likely to get into accidents compared to other age groups, often due to risky behaviors like speeding, distracted driving, and not wearing seat belts.
  3. Greater Severity of Accidents: When teens are involved in accidents, the results can be more severe due to their inexperience in handling difficult driving situations.
  4. Immaturity: Teens are still maturing in their decision-making abilities, which can lead to poor choices on the road, contributing to higher insurance premiums.
  5. Expensive Claims: The high cost of repairing newer vehicles or covering medical expenses after an accident leads to higher premiums for policyholders.
  6. Limited Credit History: Because teens typically have little or no credit history, which insurers consider when determining rates, they may face higher premiums.

What Affects Car Insurance Costs For Teens?

Certain factors cause car insurance premiums for teens to be higher than for older drivers. These factors include:

Age and Driving Experience:

  • Because teens are less experienced, they are more likely to have accidents, resulting in higher insurance premiums.

Driving Record:

  • A history of accidents or traffic violations increases insurance rates, while a clean record can help reduce them.

Type of Vehicle:

  • High-performance and sports cars are generally more expensive to insure.
  • Vehicles with advanced safety features might be eligible for lower premiums.

Location:

  • Insurance premiums are typically higher in cities with more traffic and higher crime rates.

Coverage Levels:

  • Full coverage policies cost more than minimum liability coverage.
  • Choosing a higher deductible can reduce premiums but may increase costs if a claim is made.

Credit History:

  • Although it is less relevant for teens, a limited or poor credit history can lead to higher insurance premiums.

Gender:

  • Insurance rates are often higher for young males due to their higher accident rates.

Discounts and Programs:

  • Good student discounts and safe driving programs can help reduce insurance costs.

Policy Bundling:

  • Adding a teen to an existing family policy is generally more cost-effective than purchasing a separate policy.

How Can I Add A Teen To My Car Insurance Policy?

Adding a teen to your car insurance policy is a straightforward task, but careful planning is needed to get the best coverage at a reasonable cost. Here’s how you can do it:

Notify Your Insurance Company

  • Update Your Insurer: After your teen gets a driver’s license or learner’s permit, it’s important to inform your insurance company. Some insurers might require immediate action, while others could allow you to wait until your teen has a full license.
  • Submit Required Information: Be prepared to provide your teen’s personal details, such as their driver’s license number, date of birth, and any driving history they might have.
1

Discuss Coverage Options

  • Review Your Policy Coverage: Go through your current policy to understand the coverage and decide if any changes are required. Adding a teen driver could mean higher premiums, so it’s essential to ensure your current coverage is adequate.
  • Select the Right Coverage: If your teen is driving a newer or more valuable vehicle, think about increasing your liability limits or adding comprehensive and collision coverage. Some insurance providers offer specific coverage for young drivers, so be sure to ask about that.
2

Ask About Discounts

  • Check for Teen Discounts: Insurance companies often have discounts for teen drivers, such as good student discounts, safe driving discounts, and discounts for finishing driver’s education. Ask your insurer about these options to help lower your overall cost.
  • Bundle Your Policies for Savings: If you haven’t yet, bundling your auto insurance with other policies, like home or renters insurance, can provide extra savings.
3

Evaluate The Impact On Your Premiums

  • Ask for an Insurance Quote: Request a quote from your insurer to see how much your premiums will rise when adding your teen. If you’re considering switching companies, compare this with quotes from other providers.
  • Consider Deductible Changes: Raising your deductible can lower your premium, but ensure it’s an amount you’re prepared to pay out of pocket if an accident occurs.
4

Add Your Teen To The Policy

  • Conclude the Addition: Once you’ve decided on the coverage and reviewed all available discounts, complete the process by officially adding your teen to your policy. Your insurer will then update your policy documents.
5

Educate Your Teen On Safe Driving

  • Encourage Safe Driving Practices: Urge your teen to adopt safe driving habits, as a clean driving record will help keep insurance costs lower over time. Consider signing them up for a safe driving course to potentially reduce their premiums.
6

Review The Policy Regularly

  • Annual Coverage Review: As your teen’s driving experience increases, it’s wise to review your policy every year to see if any additional discounts or adjustments in coverage are needed.
7

Car Insurance Discounts For Teens

Here are a few typical discounts available to teenage drivers to help them lower their car insurance premiums:

1.Good Student Discount

  • Teens who maintain a B average or a 3.0 GPA can qualify for this discount, as insurance companies see academically responsible students as more likely to be responsible behind the wheel.

2. Driver’s Education Discount

  • Completing a driver’s education course can reduce insurance premiums since these courses emphasize safe driving practices that help lower accident risks.

3. Safe Driving Discount

  • Insurers often provide discounts to teens who keep a clean driving record, with no accidents or traffic violations.

4. Safe Driver Programs

  • Programs such as State Farm’s Steer Clear® or GEICO’s DriveEasy reward teens for safe driving behavior, usually requiring participation in monitored driving courses or apps.

5. Low Mileage Discount

  • Teens who don’t drive frequently may be eligible for a low mileage discount, especially if they only drive occasionally, such as for school or work.

6. Student Away at School Discount

  • If your teen is attending college more than 100 miles from home and doesn’t drive regularly, some insurers offer discounts due to the reduced likelihood of the vehicle being driven.

7. Bundling Discount

  • Combining your teen’s auto insurance with existing family policies or bundling with other types of insurance, such as homeowners, can result in a multi-policy discount.

8. Accident-Free Discount

  • Teens who keep an accident-free record over time may qualify for this discount, which rewards safe driving.

9. Early Signing Discount

  • Some insurers offer discounts if you renew or sign up for a policy before the current one expires.

10. Usage-Based Insurance Programs

  • Programs like Progressive’s Snapshot® or Allstate’s Drivewise® monitor driving behavior and offer discounts for safe driving, making them particularly beneficial for teens who practice careful driving habits.

11. Good Driver Discount

  • This discount is available to young drivers who have held their license for a few years and maintained a clean driving record.

Average Cost Of Car Insurance For Teens – By State

State Average cost per month Average cost per year
Alabama $109 $1,304
Alaska $104 $1,246
Arizona $117 $1,399
Arkansas $130 $1,556
California $149 $1,783
Colorado $140 $1,675
Connecticut $165 $1,980
DC $157 $1,887
Delaware $153 $1,838
Florida $188 $2,250
Georgia $151 $1,815
Hawaii $105 $1,255
Idaho $85 $1,019
Illinois $98 $1,176
Indiana $88 $1,057
Iowa $89 $1,073
Kansas $118 $1,412
Kentucky $134 $1,611
Louisiana $186 $2,228
Maine $74 $884
Maryland $128 $1,541
Massachusetts $135 $1,616
Michigan $197 $2,368
Minnesota $112 $1,339
Mississippi $125 $1,504
Missouri $107 $1,288
Montana $132 $1,589
Nebraska $107 $1,287
Nevada $132 $1,578
New Hampshire $96 $1,156
New Jersey $118 $1,419
New Mexico $125 $1,498
New York $101 $1,214
North Carolina $98 $1,170
North Dakota $94 $1,123
Ohio $80 $959
Oklahoma $122 $1,469
Oregon $110 $1,325
Pennsylvania $120 $1,438
Rhode Island $168 $2,011
South Carolina $113 $1,353
South Dakota $104 $1,250
Tennessee $112 $1,339
Texas $137 $1,644
Utah $101 $1,212
Vermont $97 $1,166
Virginia $83 $993
Washington $109 $1,307
West Virginia $122 $1,467
Wisconsin $96 $1,147
Wyoming $131 $1,577

Our Methodology

Our evaluation method for car insurance companies involves a comprehensive review of affordability, coverage options, customer support, claims processing, discounts for teens, and financial strength. We compare these factors across insurers and review sites to identify the best protection for Ohio teen drivers.

78

Quotes Assessed

40+

Hours Of Research

25

Years Of Industry Experience

31

Brands Reviewed

FAQs

Is it cheaper to be on your parent’s policy?

Teens typically find it cheaper to be added to their parent’s insurance policy than to buy their own coverage.

Should an 18 year old have their own car insurance?

The situation matters. Staying on a parent’s policy is often more affordable, but there are times when an independent policy might be necessary.

What is the cheapest car insurance for a minor?

Affordable car insurance options can vary, but State Farm and GEICO are often among the cheapest for teen drivers, particularly with discounts.

Go back to top