Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado 2024

After thorough investigation, it has been determined that Kemper offers the most inexpensive and superior non-owner vehicle insurance in Colorado.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 26 October 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

After 16 years of living in Colorado, I know how challenging it can be to own and insure a car in the state. Many people now choose to share cars or rent them for trips beyond what public transit can offer. Non-owner insurance provides both financial protection and peace of mind.

With 15 years of experience in the insurance field and over 35 years as a car insurance buyer, I’m familiar with the insurers mentioned and have used several. All are reliable, but each one offers unique advantages to Coloradians.

Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado, 2024

Non-Owner Car Insurance, Colorado 2024

Compare Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado

Overall Rating Best Suited For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating Average Monthly Cost Get A Quote
Kemper
4.7

Cheapest Overall

A-

736

$35

Instant Quote
Farmers
4.6

Cheapest Non-Owner SR-22

A-

810

$62

Instant Quote
Progressive
4.8

Cheapest With A Clean Driving Record

A+

809

$36

Instant Quote
Travelers
4.8

Best Runner-up

A++

NR

$44

Instant Quote
State Farm
4.9

Best Overall

A++

826

$53

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Cheapest Non Owner Car Insurance Companies In Colorado


Cheapest Overall

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

If you’re looking for the cheapest non-owner car insurance in Colorado, Kemper is the clear leader. Known for covering high-risk drivers, Kemper’s policies are available throughout the state and the entire country through independent agents. While affordable, Kemper’s customer satisfaction rating is low, as per the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Yet, it’s the 11th biggest insurer in the U.S. Active-duty military members and National Guard personnel may find Kemper a good fit if they don’t own a car and regularly borrow or rent one.

With Colorado’s high cost of living, car insurance can be expensive. Traffic and the high number of uninsured drivers have made car ownership a burden for many. More residents are choosing to rent or forego car ownership, and affordable non-owner insurance offers a way to save on premiums.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Top choices for affordable non-owner insurance in Colorado
  • If an SR-22 is necessary, we can arrange it for you.
  • Superior AM Best financial robustness rating
Drawbacks
  • Many customers have raised concerns about the service offered to policyholders
  • Mobile app with low ratings

Rates For The Cheapest Non Owner Car Insurance In Colorado

Insurance company Monthly Rate
Kemper $22
State Farm $42
GEICO $26
Farmers $66
Nationwide $82

Cheapest Non Owner SR-22

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Farmers is a leading provider of non-owner car insurance, particularly for drivers needing an SR-22. This form is required for high-risk drivers who have committed violations such as DUIs or reckless driving.

What sets Farmers apart is their focus on high-risk drivers. They offer SR-22 insurance and assist with reinstating suspended licenses, providing a smooth experience for those who need it most.

Farmers offers SR-22 insurance at a rate that’s only about 2% higher than standard car insurance. This makes them an affordable and comprehensive choice for drivers in Colorado who need this coverage.

For high-risk drivers who don’t own a vehicle but need to drive, non-owner SR-22 insurance is a practical solution. It provides liability protection and ensures financial responsibility in the event of an accident while driving a rental or borrowed car.

It also helps drivers maintain continuous coverage, which can prevent future premium increases due to gaps in insurance history.

Farmers is a leading provider of non-owner car insurance, particularly for drivers needing an SR-22. This form is required for high-risk drivers who have committed violations such as DUIs or reckless driving.

What sets Farmers apart is their focus on high-risk drivers. They offer SR-22 insurance and assist with reinstating suspended licenses, providing a smooth experience for those who need it most.

Farmers offers SR-22 insurance at a rate that’s only about 2% higher than standard car insurance. This makes them an affordable and comprehensive choice for drivers in Colorado who need this coverage.

For high-risk drivers who don’t own a vehicle but need to drive, non-owner SR-22 insurance is a practical solution. It provides liability protection and ensures financial responsibility in the event of an accident while driving a rental or borrowed car.

It also helps drivers maintain continuous coverage, which can prevent future premium increases due to gaps in insurance history.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Expertise in handling clients classified as high-risk drivers.
  • Competitive rates on SR-22 coverage for individuals without a vehicle.
  • Extensive range of insurance plans
Drawbacks
  • Certain customers of insurance companies have encountered issues related to the handling and resolution of their claims.
  • Greater expenses for those with a higher likelihood of accidents

Rates For The Cheapest Non-Owner SR-22 In Colorado

Insurance company Monthly Rate
Farmers $40
Nationwide $92
State Farm $42
Progressive $85
Travelers $94

Cheapest With A Clean Driving Record

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Progressive is a leading provider of non-owner car insurance in Colorado, particularly for drivers with a good driving record. Their non-owner insurance offers necessary liability coverage, protecting drivers from the costs of injury or property damage they may cause in an accident. This is important as Colorado requires financial responsibility for all vehicles in use or parked on its roads.

Progressive sells non-owner policies through independent agents and handles servicing directly. With excellent financial ratings and reliable claims-paying ability, Progressive is a solid choice. Drivers with clean records receive lower rates due to their lower risk, which rewards safe driving habits and helps reduce insurance costs.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Many different insurance plans
  • Competitive rates for skilled motorists
  • Special offers for mindful drivers
Drawbacks
  • Rental car fees are not reimbursed.
  • Heterogeneous customer service comments
  • Non-owner auto insurance may not be offered in all states

Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance Rates With A Clean Driving Record

Insurance company Monthly rate
Nationwide $50
GEICO $46
State Farm $50
Progressive $32
Farmers $55

Best Overall Non Owner Car Insurance

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claim Payouts
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

State Farm is a leading choice for non-owner car insurance in Colorado, offering a winning combination of competitive pricing, comprehensive coverage, and excellent customer service.

At $213 per year, State Farm’s non-owner liability policy is much cheaper than the state average of $323. Though not the least expensive, the value of the customer service makes the price well worth it.

State Farm’s non-owner insurance includes liability protection, shielding you financially if you’re at fault for injury or property damage. If you already have an auto policy with State Farm, comprehensive coverage may also apply to rental cars.

State Farm’s commitment to excellent customer service sets it apart. With quick access via phone or mobile app, help is readily available when you need it most.

While price matters, having great customer service provides peace of mind that’s just as important as saving on premiums. The ability to handle claims quickly and provide assistance makes a big difference.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Value-based pricing
  • Extensive protection
  • Great customer happiness
Drawbacks
  • The deficiency of comprehensive or collision insurance in non-owner policies.
  • There's a restricted amount of discounts available.
  • Cheaper options are within reach.

Best Runner-Up

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

When considering non-owner car insurance in Colorado, Travelers stands out as our best runner-up due to their tailored policies and exceptional customer service.

Travelers is well-regarded for their superior customer service, which is a vital factor in selecting an insurance provider. If an accident or claim occurs, you want an insurer that responds promptly and effectively. Travelers has consistently shown its dedication to customer satisfaction, making it a trustworthy choice for non-owner car insurance.

In addition to great service, Travelers offers a comprehensive range of coverage options, including standard liability, collision, and uninsured/underinsured coverage, providing affordable protection.

Non-owner car insurance primarily offers liability coverage for damages you may cause to others. However, adding comprehensive and collision coverage can enhance your overall protection, making it a smart decision for many drivers.

Comprehensive coverage protects against incidents unrelated to collisions, such as theft, vandalism, or natural disaster damage, ensuring you’re not financially affected if such events happen.

Collision coverage provides protection if you’re involved in an accident with another vehicle or object, regardless of fault.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • All-inclusive insurance
  • Exceptional customer satisfaction
  • Reasonable rates
Drawbacks
  • Pricing information not online.
  • Short-lived sales
  • Greater costs for drivers posing higher insurance risks

What Is Non-Owner Car Insurance

If you often find yourself driving vehicles that don’t belong to you, such as rental cars or those borrowed from friends or family, it may be wise to look into non-owner car insurance.

This insurance primarily provides liability coverage. If you’re responsible for an accident while driving someone else’s vehicle, your non-owner policy can cover the medical and repair expenses of the other party involved.

Some insurance companies might offer additional options like uninsured/underinsured motorist protection and personal injury protection.

However, it’s essential to understand that non-owner insurance typically does not cover comprehensive or collision damage. This means that any damage to the vehicle you’re driving may not be included in your coverage.

For those who frequently rent cars or borrow vehicles, non-owner car insurance can be quite advantageous. It adds a layer of security beyond the coverage that the vehicle’s owner already has.

In many instances, it can be more economical than always opting for rental company insurance.

Additionally, holding a non-owner policy helps maintain continuous insurance coverage, which could lead to lower premiums if you decide to buy a vehicle in the future.

Coverage Type Non-Owner Car Insurance Full Coverage Policy
Liability Coverage Covers bodily injury and property damage you cause to others. Covers bodily injury and property damage you cause to others.
Comprehensive Coverage Does not cover damages to the vehicle you’re driving from non-collision incidents like theft, fire, or vandalism. Covers damages to your vehicle from non-collision incidents like theft, fire, or vandalism.
Collision Coverage Does not cover damages to the vehicle you’re driving from a collision, regardless of fault. Covers damages to your vehicle from a collision, regardless of fault.
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Protection Optional. Some insurers offer this as an additional coverage. Can cover your losses if you’re involved in an accident with an uninsured or underinsured driver.
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Optional. Some insurers offer this as an additional coverage. Can cover medical expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of who is at fault.
Rental Car Coverage Provides liability coverage when you rent a vehicle. Typically requires additional rental reimbursement coverage.

What Is SR-22 Insurance?

An SR-22 is technically not classified as an insurance policy; rather, it is a vehicle liability insurance document required by many state DMVs for “high-risk” insurance policies.

This form, filed by your insurance company, provides proof that you maintain the minimum liability insurance coverage mandated by your state.

It is commonly required for drivers whose licenses have been suspended due to traffic violations, DUIs, or other serious offenses.

The SR-22 functions as a certificate of financial responsibility, confirming that the driver has the necessary auto liability insurance coverage. Its main purpose is to ensure that individuals are maintaining the required level of liability insurance.

Typically, this document is required by the state or through court orders, particularly for high-risk drivers. The insurance company submits this form to the state, and if the policy lapses at any point, the insurer must notify the state.

Average Cost Of Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado

The world of non-owner car insurance can be confusing, with so many providers and varying rates. It’s vital to make an informed decision, especially when considering the costs involved.

To help clarify things, we’ve created a comparison chart that shows the average prices of non-owner car insurance from five major providers.

Insurer Average Monthly Rate
State Farm $84
Nationwide $82
Progressive $82
GEICO $74
Travelers $72

How Much Is Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado – By Age?

As with full coverage car insurance, non-owner car insurance rates are steepest for teenage drivers, gradually decreasing each year until age 55.

The following are sample rates for non-owner car insurance in Colorado for ten different ages.

Age Average Annual Rate
16 $1,252
17 $1,048
18 $838
19 $575
20 $526
21 $398
22 $375
23 $358
24 $345
25 $325
30 $310
35 $295
40 $290
45 $286
50 $280
55 $278
60 $280
65 $300
70 $314
75 $360

How Non-Owner Insurance Rates In Colorado Compare To Rates In Other States

Surprisingly, Colorado’s non-owner car insurance averages $290 annually, lower than the national average of $353. Rates in the 12 most populous states:

State Average Annual Premium
North Carolina $992
Florida $675
New York $590
Michigan $585
Texas $419
Illinois $292
Georgia $384
National Average $353
Pennsylvania $220
California $323
Ohio $200

Average Cost Of Non Owner Car Insurance In Colorado Cities

Shown are the indicative prices for five smaller Colorado towns.

City Sample Average Annual Rate
Cimarron $236
Montrose $237
Bedrock $238
Naturita $234
Nucla $235

How Much Is Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado’s 10 Biggest Cities?

The population size of a city is key in determining car insurance costs. Cities with more traffic generally see higher insurance rates.

City Average Annual Rate
Pueblo $328
Westminster $328
Arvada $325
Greeley $286
Fort Collins $282
Aurora $368
Lakewood $347
Denver $344
Thornton $334
Colorado Springs $329

How To Get Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado

These five steps will guide you in securing non-owner car insurance in Colorado without hassle.

Understand Your Needs

Before you get started, it’s crucial to recognize the reasons you need non-owner car insurance. Are you regularly renting vehicles or borrowing from family and friends?

1

Gather Your Personal Information

To receive a quote for non-owner car insurance, you must provide basic personal information, such as your name, address, and driver’s license number. This data allows the insurer to assess your risk level and determine your premium.

2

Compare Rates From Different Providers

Not all insurance companies charge the same rates for non-owner car insurance. Comparing quotes from various providers is strongly encouraged to secure the best deal.

3

Choose The Right Coverage

Non-owner car insurance policies typically include liability coverage, which pays for costs if you cause an accident. Depending on your needs and the insurance provider, you may have the option to add extra coverage, like uninsured motorist protection or medical payments. It’s crucial to select a policy that addresses your specific needs.

4

Purchase Your Policy And Obtain Proof Of Insurance

Once you’ve made your policy choice, you can usually buy it online or over the phone. After completing the purchase, you’ll often receive proof of insurance promptly, typically via email. If required, your provider can also file an SR-22 for you.

5

Should You Get Non-Owner Car Insurance In Colorado?

Non-owner car insurance is an auto insurance policy made for individuals without a car who still drive from time to time. It offers liability protection if you cause an accident while operating a rented or borrowed vehicle.

In Colorado, different types of people should think about acquiring non-owner car insurance.

Frequent Renters And Borrowers

For those who regularly rent cars or borrow from friends and family, non-owner car insurance is an excellent option to consider. While rental companies do offer insurance, it can be quite expensive if you rent frequently.

Additionally, although the owner’s insurance might cover some incidents, having your own policy ensures you’re protected without affecting their premium.

Public Transport Commuters With Occasional Driving Needs

A lot of Coloradians utilize public transportation or rideshare options for their daily commutes, driving only sporadically. You might be among them if you live in an urban area with great public transit or if you prefer biking or walking most of the time.

However, there may be times when driving is necessary. In those situations, having non-owner insurance provides the financial protection you need.

Individuals Trying To Maintain Continuous Coverage

Insurance companies often see drivers without continuous coverage as high-risk, potentially leading to higher rates when you want to buy a car. If you’ve sold your vehicle and will be without one for a while, opting for a non-owner policy can help maintain your insurance history. This is particularly useful when you’re ready to purchase a car again.

What Does Non-Owner Car Insurance Cover?

A non-owner car insurance policy mainly provides liability coverage, which covers costs related to bodily injury or property damage you may cause to others in an accident. It’s important to keep in mind that this policy does not cover damages to the vehicle you’re driving; those are typically covered by the owner’s insurance.

Some policies may also offer optional features such as medical payments or personal injury protection (PIP) to cover your medical expenses after an accident, regardless of fault. Additionally, uninsured/underinsured motorist protection is another feature that can be added to safeguard you in case you collide with a driver who lacks adequate insurance.

However, it’s essential to understand that non-owner car insurance does not include comprehensive or collision coverage, which means damages to the vehicle you’re driving due to theft, vandalism, or accidents are usually not included.

Our Methodology

Based on a detailed analysis that includes customer service evaluations, product variety, pricing comparisons, and insights from online reviews, I've developed a comprehensive understanding of non-owner car insurance providers. This perspective is informed by my 15 years as a licensed agent, interacting with different company representatives and navigating Colorado's insurance market.

124

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

41

Brands Reviewed

30+

Research Hours

FAQs

Do you need car insurance if you don’t own a car in Colorado?

Yes, car insurance is mandatory in Colorado, regardless of whether you own the vehicle or not. Non-owner car insurance addresses this by offering liability coverage for accidents that occur while driving a borrowed or rented vehicle.

Can I buy auto insurance for someone else’s car in Colorado?

Absolutely, you can purchase auto insurance for another person’s car in Colorado. However, it’s not as simple as insuring your own vehicle. Though the owner doesn’t necessarily need to be the policyholder, insurance companies generally prefer that the person buying the insurance has a vested interest in the car, such as being a co-owner or frequent driver. If you drive the car often but don’t own it, a non-owner car insurance policy might be more suitable.

Who offers the cheapest non owners car insurance in Colorado?

Based on our study, Kemper offers the most competitive prices for non-owner car insurance in Colorado.

Go back to top