Best Condo Insurance In New York 2024
The best condo insurance in New York comes from Nationwide.
We’ve saved shoppers an average of $450 per year on their home insurance.
In this guide, I will outline how to choose the best condo insurance in New York. My experience as a licensed insurance agent has shown me how vital it is to have comprehensive coverage—not just for financial protection, but also for peace of mind.
Don’t skip out on insurance; choose an extensive condo policy that covers all types of losses, including theft and natural disasters. Continue to read for guidance on securing full protection for both you and your condo.
Best Condo Insurance In New York, 2024
Compare The Best Condo Insurance In New York
| Overall Rating | Best For | A.M Best Rating | J.D Power Rating | Get A Quote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nationwide |
|
Overall |
A+ |
816 |
Instant Quote |
| Amica |
|
Runner-Up |
A+ |
849 |
Instant Quote |
| Chubb |
|
High-Value Condos |
A++ |
809 |
Instant Quote |
| Travelers |
|
Discounts |
A |
794 |
Instant Quote |
The Best Condo Insurance Companies In New York
Best For Discounts
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅If you’re looking for savings, Travelers Insurance is a top contender. It provides a variety of discounts for condo owners, resulting in reduced insurance premiums while still offering comprehensive coverage.
Travelers Insurance provides a multi-policy discount, allowing you to save up to 15% on condo insurance when you bundle it with car and other policies. This discount not only reduces costs but also makes your insurance management simpler.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Discounts provided when bundling
- Financially reliable
- Attractive rates ✓
- More frequent complaints than leading brands
- Possibility of a banned breed policy
- Limited service coverage ✘
Best Runner-Up
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Amica is an outstanding condo insurance provider, known for its top-tier customer service and extensive coverage options. They offer broad coverage and up to 20% savings when bundling auto and condo insurance. Their Platinum policy also delivers enhanced protection through additional and extended coverages.
Their pricing is competitive, with lower rates than some top rivals, including Allstate. The minimal number of complaints further highlights their strong customer satisfaction.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- High customer approval ratings
- A variety of coverage choices
- Superior financial security ✓
- Rates are higher than the norm
- AM Best rating saw a downgrade in 2017
- Dividend policies not accessible in New York ✘
Best Overall
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Condo owners in New York should prioritize Nationwide when looking for insurance due to its robust coverage and useful add-ons. For example, they offer coverage for fixtures, additions, installations, improvements, and alterations.
Besides offering tailored protection for you, your unit, and your belongings, Nationwide will also reimburse you for extra expenses if damage to your home forces you to live elsewhere.
The company is recognized for its efficient and smooth claims handling. Their dedicated customer service team promptly delivers fair resolutions, which drives customer satisfaction.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Reasonably priced
- Very few complaints
- Excellent for broad coverage ✓
- Not ideal for lower-value condos
- Potential for premium increases
- Discounts may not last indefinitely ✘
Best For High-Value Condos
Key Statistics
Why We Like Them
⇅Chubb’s Masterpiece policy is a great choice for luxury condo insurance. It provides extended replacement cost and gives you the flexibility to add coverages like identity theft and cyber protection.
High-net-worth homeowners in New York can find the perfect insurance for their high-value condos with Chubb’s tailored solutions.
Benefits & Drawbacks
⇅- Few Complaints from Customers
- Excellent Service Standards
- Availability of Comprehensive Coverage ✓
- No BBB Accreditation
- Higher Costs for Less Valuable Properties
- More Expensive than Main Competitors ✘
How much condo insurance is required in New York?
Condo owners in New York aren’t legally obligated to have insurance, but mortgage lenders or condo associations often require it. Typically, condo insurance policies include liability coverage ranging from $100,000 to $500,000.
How much condo insurance do I need in New York?
The required condo insurance in New York varies depending on your condo’s structure, the value of your personal property, and the protection offered by your condo association’s master policy. You may also consider adding loss assessment coverage to your policy for additional protection against damage or loss in shared areas.
How to find the best condo insurance company for you
Your condo may be one of your most important investments, so getting the right insurance coverage to protect it from financial loss is essential. However, finding the policy that best suits your needs may require time and effort. To make this process smoother, here are five steps you can take to safeguard yourself, your family, and your property:
- Assess how much condo insurance you need.
- Search online for condo insurance companies and pick three that seem most trustworthy.
- Request quotes from all three.
- Compare the coverage options, rates, financial stability, customer satisfaction, and discounts.
- Apply for coverage with the most suitable provider.
What does condo insurance cover in New York?
In New York, condominium insurance, also known as HO6, typically offers protection for everything inside the unit, including walls, flooring, fixtures, cabinets, and personal belongings, against damage or theft. Most policies also provide loss assessment coverage for common areas, with endorsement amounts usually starting at $1,000 and often being adjustable.
How Much Is Condo Insurance In New York?
Condo insurance needs differ from person to person. To help you choose wisely, I’ve assembled the following cost comparison tables for condo insurance:
Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Building Property Limits
The right condo insurance coverage depends on the value of both your condo and personal property. The table below compares the average annual costs for different building property limits in New York.
| Building Property Limit | Average Annual Rate |
| $40,000 | $440 |
| $60,000 | $510 |
| $80,000 | $567 |
| $100,000 | $631 |
Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Company
This final table shows the average yearly cost of condo insurance in New York, compared across 10 prominent national insurance companies.
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate |
| State Farm | $309 |
| Chubb | $718 |
| American Family | $450 |
| AIG | $1,098 |
| Farmers | $921 |
| Travelers | $533 |
| Nationwide | $800 |
| Allstate | $625 |
Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By City
In the next table, you’ll find the average condo insurance costs, both monthly and annually, for residents of 10 major cities in New York.
| City | Average Annual Rate |
| Yonkers | $652 |
| New York City | $790 |
| White plains | $669 |
| Utica | $583 |
| Warwick | $640 |
| Saratoga Springs | $566 |
| Ithaca | $590 |
| Rochester | $557 |
| Syracuse | $625 |
The costs presented in the tables are only estimates and can vary based on factors such as your specific insurance needs, the location of your condo, and its structural details.
Besides cost, take into account other factors when selecting a policy. You should aim for comprehensive coverage and choose an insurer known for its financial stability and good customer service.
How to get an online condo insurance quote in New York
The best approach to finding the right policy to protect your New York condo is to request quotes from different home insurance providers within the state. I recommend using Insuranceopedia to compare the coverage options offered by various insurers.
For accurate quotes, you’ll need to give certain details, such as:
- Personal information: This includes your name, location, insurance history, and how many people live in your condo.
- Personal property value: How much are your belongings worth that you want to insure?
- Replacement cost of your condo: What is the estimated cost to rebuild your unit with the same materials if it’s damaged?
- Condo details: You’ll provide details about your condo, such as its age, square footage, type of exterior walls, and installed safety features.
Find Condo Insurance In New York
Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Condo Insurance Policy
Several factors play a significant role in determining your condo insurance cost in New York, including:
Replacement Cost
The replacement cost represents the estimated amount required to rebuild your condo unit if it were to suffer damage. A higher replacement value will generally result in increased insurance rates.
Age and Building Materials
Insurance premiums tend to be higher for older condominiums because they are more likely to suffer from damage due to outdated electrical and plumbing systems. The type of materials used in construction can also impact premiums; condos with fire-resistant materials may have lower premiums in New York.
Claims History
Having previous insurance claims might cause insurers to consider you a higher risk, which could increase your condo insurance premiums. However, a claims-free history may help decrease your insurance rates.
Physical Address
If your condo is situated in a high-risk New York area with high crime rates or severe weather conditions, you’ll probably face higher insurance premiums. New York’s recurring wildfires also make condo insurance more expensive.
Our Methodology
I identified the top condo insurance providers in New York by analyzing J.D. Power's customer satisfaction data, considering AM Best’s credit ratings, reading consumer reviews, and using my professional background as a former licensed property and casualty agent in New York, where I sold condo insurance.
Quotes Analyzed
Brands Reviewed
Years Of Experience
Research Hours
FAQs
How does condo insurance work?
Condo insurance provides coverage for the repair or replacement of your unit’s interior and personal belongings in case of damage or theft. It also offers liability protection and fills in coverage gaps left by your condominium’s master policy, helping to safeguard you against financial loss.
How much is condo insurance in New York?
Condo owners in New York pay an average of $56 per month or $670 per year for condo insurance. These rates vary depending on various factors, including your location, coverage limits, claims history, and your association’s master policy.
Sources
⇅