Life Insurance Companies In Indiana For 2024

My research points to MassMutual being the top-rated life insurance company in Indiana.

min read -
Updated: 15 October 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

After researching, I’ve found that MassMutual is the best life insurance company in Indiana, not because of its market dominance, but because it delivers excellent coverage and service at a competitive price, which makes it a strong option.

In addition to MassMutual, our rankings highlighted Mutual of Omaha as the best for seniors, Transamerica as a top pick for younger individuals, State Farm for customer service, and Nationwide as a great option for smokers. MassMutual also took the lead in providing the lowest-priced life insurance in Indiana.

Reading the results below won’t take long, but it’s a great use of your time. Without the proper life insurance, your family might not enjoy the life you envision for them if something happens to you. Purchasing life insurance shows your dedication to their future.

Best Life Insurance Companies In Indiana 2024

transamerica-icon-logo
Best for Seniors - Mutual of Omaha
transamerica-icon-logo
Best for Young People - Transamerica
nationwide-icon-logo
Best for Smokers - Nationwide
Best Life Insurance, Indiana, 2024

Compare The Best Life Insurance Companies In Indiana

To simplify your assessment of the top life insurance companies in Indiana, we’ve included a table highlighting our recommended providers based on key criteria.

A.M. Best Rating Best For Overall Rating Online Experience J.D. Power Rating Get A Quote
State Farm

A++

Best for Customer Service

4.8

9.5

839

Instant Quote
MassMutual

A++

Best Overall

4.8

9.7

780

Instant Quote
Transamerica

A

Young Adults

4.7

9.8

740

Instant Quote
Mutual of Omaha

A+

Seniors

4.6

9.7

801

Instant Quote
MassMutual

A++

Best for Cheapest Life Insurance

4.8

9.7

780

Instant Quote
Nationwide

A+

Best for Smokers

4.6

9.6

791

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Life Insurance Companies In Indiana 2024


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

MassMutual received the title of Best Overall because of its many strengths. The company offers a broad selection of life insurance products, including term, whole, and universal life, at competitive prices, along with a diverse range of riders to meet various needs.

MassMutual’s team of “career agents” is highly knowledgeable, having received extensive training on the company’s life insurance product line. Their exclusive focus on MassMutual products gives them an advantage in helping customers understand the ins and outs of life insurance.

Another key consideration was MassMutual’s financial strength. It earned the top rating of A++ Superior from AM Best, recognizing its strong financial foundation and ability to pay claims.

MassMutual’s designation as Best Overall is a result of its commitment to providing a wide array of products supported by a highly trained sales team, rather than just offering low prices. Though it may not have the same brand recognition or market share in Indiana, it is a trusted and respected name in the state.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Wide product selection with many rider options
  • Best prices in Indiana for life insurance
  • Superior financial ratings
Drawbacks
  • Must be purchased through MassMutual agents
  • J.D. Power rating is lower than some major competitors
  • No online purchase available for whole life policies

Best for Young Adults

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Transamerica is well aware of its strength in providing affordable life insurance for young adults. The company understands that young people tend to be more budget-conscious, particularly with life insurance, and has therefore priced its policies to ensure younger consumers can get adequate coverage without overspending.

Transamerica’s website is crafted for younger customers who value easy-to-understand, concise information. The site is user-friendly and informative, allowing customers to navigate their options without difficulty. Transamerica believes that life insurance should provide peace of mind for everyone, regardless of their age or budget.

Life insurance companies face difficulties in reaching younger buyers since many delay purchasing until after marriage or having children. Despite this, firms like Transamerica focus on this market because of its lower mortality rates, which offer better profit potential.

In our review, Transamerica had the lowest customer service rating. This may be due to their reliance on independent insurance agents, where some solo agents might not deliver top-notch service.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Face values as high as $10 million
  • Term life insurance available online
  • No medical exam required for eligible applicants seeking up to $2 million in coverage
Drawbacks
  • Customer service ratings are lower than those of competitors
  • Minimum face amount for term life is $25,000

Best for Seniors

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Mutual of Omaha is highly respected for its expertise in senior insurance. For many years, seniors have relied on the company, thanks not only to the well-loved “Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom” show but also to the extensive training provided to agents specializing in the senior market.

The insurance company is noted for its senior life insurance products, which include two options catering to seniors with health problems. One of these is a guaranteed-issue policy that doesn’t require a medical exam or health questions, making it well-suited for those with serious medical conditions like cancer, stroke, or heart attack.

The second product is a simplified-issue policy that involves answering medical history questions but does not require a medical examination. It’s an ideal choice for seniors with minor health issues such as high blood pressure or type 2 diabetes who wish to avoid medical exams.

Seniors generally pay the most for life insurance, and many trust Mutual of Omaha. The company has been a significant force in senior insurance products, including Medicare supplements and life insurance, for years. Baby Boomers and their parents have known and trusted the company since they were young.

Moreover, Mutual of Omaha is highly recognized in the senior insurance space, supported by its successful direct mail outreach to seniors and the thorough training of its agents in the company’s product line.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Highly secure financially
  • Senior-friendly rates in Indiana
  • Offers peace of mind through well-trained agents
Drawbacks
  • Has a higher complaint ratio than some other insurers
  • Lower agent presence in Indiana compared to competitors

Best for Customer Service

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

J.D. Powers has consistently ranked State Farm highly for customer satisfaction in life insurance, reflecting the company’s strong focus on providing great service. This isn’t surprising, considering State Farm has the largest network of agents in the country.

Policyholders recognize and appreciate State Farm’s commitment to delivering excellent customer service. The company’s local offices, found in many neighborhoods, make it easy for policyholders to meet with their agents for in-person assistance.

State Farm is well known for providing exceptional customer service and fast claim processing, which is crucial in life insurance, as families facing loss depend on their insurer for swift and caring support.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Holds excellent financial ratings for claim payment reliability
  • Has a much lower rate of customer complaints than industry norms
  • More service agents than any other insurer
Drawbacks
  • Offers a smaller selection of riders
  • Policies must be purchased via State Farm

Best For Cheapest Life Insurance

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Recognized as the leading life insurance company in Louisiana, MassMutual also leads financially, offering some of the most competitive rates. Even with many low-cost term insurers in the state, MassMutual continues to provide the best pricing.

While price shouldn’t be the sole consideration when buying life insurance, it remains an important factor. MassMutual, often associated with professionalism, offers the most competitive rates in Louisiana. The company is working to increase its market share in the state with aggressive pricing.

Price is a major factor in life insurance purchases in the current economy. MassMutual is a great option for its budget-friendly premiums and high coverage amounts. While whole and universal life policies are less competitive, term life insurance offers larger coverage since permanent insurance is typically more expensive.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • MassMutual policies are sold through an extensive network of trained agents
  • The most affordable life insurance option in Indiana
  • Full range of life insurance products offered
Drawbacks
  • Life insurance must be bought through a MassMutual agent
  • No online application available

Best for Smokers

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Nationwide has built a strong reputation with numerous local offices available for sales and service. Their slogan, “Nationwide is on your side,” is especially meaningful for smokers in Louisiana seeking life insurance. While their smoker rates may be slightly higher than those of their competitors, we concluded that they are the best option thanks to competitive rates, agent accessibility, and excellent customer service.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Many offices located across Indiana
  • Offers a wide range of life insurance products
  • Nationwide policies are distributed through an extensive network of trained agents
Drawbacks
  • Policies must be bought through a Nationwide agent
  • No online application option for life insurance

How To Find The Best Life Insurance Company For You

In Indiana, finding the right life insurance requires knowing that there’s no perfect option for everyone. At Insuranceopedia, we take into account different needs, reviewing multiple insurers and awarding companies in various categories.

To choose the right life insurance for your situation, follow these three steps:

  1. Find out how much life insurance coverage you need. Most life insurers provide “life insurance calculators” on their websites to help with this calculation.
  2. Choose three insurers to compare. Don’t just focus on rates; it’s equally important to ensure the company is financially sound. Low premiums are meaningless if the insurer is unable to pay your claims.
  3. Take the next step and apply for coverage. Many shoppers stop short of buying a policy, but your family’s financial future is too important to delay.

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Life Insurance In Indiana

Multiple factors influence life insurance rates in Indiana, such as:

  • Your life insurance company
  • Age
  • Gender
  • Health status
  • Smoking habits
  • Credit score
  • Riders added to your policy

Men often pay higher premiums than women due to their shorter life expectancy. Smokers also face higher rates for the same reason. In Indiana, your credit score may also be factored into your insurance rate. Adding riders, like a disability waiver of premium or child coverage, can further raise the cost of your policy.

Largest Life Insurance Companies In Indiana

The state of Indiana features a diverse range of life insurance providers. Here are the five leading companies by market share:

Company Market Share
Northwestern Mutual 11.20%
MassMutual 4.35%
New York Life 3.86%
State Farm 3.72%
Southern Farm Bureau Life Insurance 3.18%

Average Life Insurance Rates in Indiana For Females

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $632,000 Coverage
Mass Mutual $10 $14
Mutual of Omaha $11 $15
GEICO $11 $23
Prudential $14 $28
Allstate $20 $33

*Rates based on a 10-year term life policy for a 30-year-old female nonsmoker

Average Life Insurance Rates in Indiana For Males

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $632,000 Coverage
Mass Mutual $10 $16
Mutual of Omaha $11 $17
GEICO $12 $18
Prudential $15 $30
Allstate $19 $34

**Rates based on a 10-year term life policy for a 30-year-old male nonsmoker

Average Life Insurance Rates in Indiana For Smokers

Company Average Monthly Cost
Nationwide $50
Mutual of Omaha $51
GEICO $40
Prudential $42
Allstate $45

*Rates based on $632,000 of 20-year term life for a 30-year-old male smoker

If you’re a smoker, you’ll pay higher premiums for life insurance. However, you can lower your rates to those of non-smokers by proving you’ve quit for 12-24 months, depending on the insurer. A paramedical exam and a blood test will be required to verify that your system is nicotine-free.

Average Life Insurance Rates in Indiana For Seniors

Company Monthly Cost
Mutual of Omaha $89
AAA $143
Nationwide $77
State Farm $150
Haven $168

*Based on $75,000 of coverage for a 60 year old male non-smoker buying a 10 year term life contract.

Average Life Insurance Rates in Indiana For Young Adults

Company Monthly Cost
Mutual of Omaha $15
AAA $23
Nationwide $14
State Farm $27
Haven $20

*Rates are for a 25-year-old male nonsmoker that purchases a $250,000 20-year term life policy.

Indiana Life Insurance Laws To Know

Indiana has established specific guidelines to protect life insurance policyholders. If you’re considering getting life insurance in the state, be aware of these protections, which include:

Contestable period

According to Indiana’s legal provisions, life insurers can reject a claim if the policyholder’s application contains misleading or false details, provided it’s within two years of the policy being active. After two years, the insurer loses the right to contest any discrepancies.

Grace period for missed payments

If you miss a payment on your life insurance, Indiana law grants a 30-day grace period so you can pay without a lapse in coverage.

Free Look Period

Once you’ve been issued your life insurance policy, you have 10 days to review it. If you find it’s not what you want, you can return it during that time and get a full refund of any premiums paid, without any fees or penalties.

Time allowable to settle a claim

In order to receive the life insurance benefits, the beneficiaries must file a claim, and all insurers in Indiana are obligated to settle claims within 30 days.

How Much Life Insurance Do You Need In Indiana?

How much life insurance you need depends on your situation. Homeowners tend to need more coverage than renters, and those with children or other dependents usually require greater protection.

Generally, agents advise having life insurance worth 10 to 20 times your annual salary. For instance, if you make $75,000 a year, your policy might need to be between $750,000 and $1.5 million.

Our Methodology

Our selection process for the best life insurance companies was comprehensive and detailed. We looked at several factors, including customer service, product options, pricing, and online functionality. Additionally, my experience as a life insurance agent and my work with other insurers provided valuable insights into their offerings. While price was a factor in our selection, we did not focus solely on it, except in the "Best for Cheapest Life Insurance" category. We believe that each of these companies is outstanding in their niche, and price shouldn’t be the only consideration when choosing life insurance.

34

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years of experience

18

Brands reviewed

27+

Research hours

FAQs

Is life insurance more expensive in Indiana?

Life insurance pricing in Indiana is generally in line with other states. Insurers that charge higher premiums often do so after facing more claims than anticipated.

How much per month is a million-dollar life insurance policy in Indiana?

The best rate for a 10-year term life insurance policy worth $1 million in Indiana is from MassMutual, with a monthly premium of $25.

What is the average monthly cost of life insurance in Indiana?

The cost of life insurance for a 30-year-old man in Indiana can start at $9.99 monthly for $250,000 in coverage, and for a woman, it’s around $9.40.

Go back to top